As Reported by House Ways and Means Committee            1            

123rd General Assembly                                             4            

   Regular Session                            Am. H. B. No. 595    5            

      1999-2000                                                    6            


        REPRESENTATIVES D. MILLER-ALLEN-SCHULER-DePIERO-           8            

      SULLIVAN-JONES-BARRETT-JERSE-ROBINSON-HARTNETT-PERRY         9            


_________________________________________________________________   10           

                          A   B I L L                                           

             To amend sections 323.151 to 323.157, 323.99, and     12           

                5715.30 and to enact section 323.159 of the        13           

                Revised Code to permit occupants of housing        14           

                cooperatives to apply for the homestead                         

                exemption.                                                      




BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF OHIO:        16           

      Section 1.  That sections 323.151, 323.152, 323.153,         18           

323.154, 323.155, 323.156, 323.157, 323.99, and 5715.30 be         19           

amended and section 323.159 of the Revised Code be enacted to      20           

read as follows:                                                                

      Sec. 323.151.  As used in sections 323.151 to 323.157        29           

323.159 of the Revised Code:                                       31           

      (A)  "Homestead" means a EITHER OF THE FOLLOWING:            33           

      (1)  A dwelling, including a unit in a multiple-unit         36           

dwelling and a manufactured home or mobile home taxed as real      37           

property pursuant to division (B) of section 4503.06 of the        38           

Revised Code, owned and occupied as a home by an individual whose  40           

domicile is in this state and who has not acquired ownership from  41           

a person, other than the individual's spouse, related by           43           

consanguinity or affinity for the purpose of qualifying for the    44           

real property tax reduction provided in section 323.152 of the     45           

Revised Code.  The                                                              

      (2)  A UNIT IN A HOUSING COOPERATIVE THAT IS OCCUPIED AS A   47           

HOME, BUT NOT OWNED, BY AN INDIVIDUAL WHOSE DOMICILE IS IN THIS    48           

STATE.                                                                          

                                                          2      


                                                                 
      THE homestead shall include so much of the land surrounding  51           

it, not exceeding one acre, as is reasonably necessary for the     52           

use of the dwelling or unit as a home.  An owner includes a        53           

holder of one of the several estates in fee, a vendee in           54           

possession under a purchase agreement or a land contract, a        56           

mortgagor, a life tenant, one or more tenants with a right of      58           

survivorship, tenants in common, and a settlor of a revocable      59           

inter vivos trust holding the title to a homestead occupied by     60           

the settlor as of right under the trust.  The tax commissioner     61           

shall adopt rules for the uniform classification and valuation of  62           

real property or portions of real property as homesteads.          63           

      (B)  "Sixty-five years of age or older" means a person who   65           

has attained age sixty-four prior to the first day of January of   66           

the year of application for reduction in real estate taxes.        67           

      (C)  "Total income" means the adjusted gross income of the   69           

owner and the owner's spouse for the year preceding the year in    71           

which application for a reduction in taxes is made, as determined  72           

under the "Internal Revenue Code of 1986," 100 Stat. 2085, 26      73           

U.S.C.A. 1, as amended, adjusted as follows:                       74           

      (1)  Subtract the amount of disability benefits included in  76           

adjusted gross income, but not to exceed fifty-two hundred         77           

dollars;                                                           78           

      (2)  Add old age and survivors benefits received pursuant    80           

to the "Social Security Act" that are not included in adjusted     81           

gross income;                                                      82           

      (3)  Add retirement, pension, annuity, or other retirement   84           

payments or benefits not included in adjusted gross income;        85           

      (4)  Add tier I and tier II railroad retirement benefits     87           

received pursuant to the "Railroad Retirement Act," 50 Stat. 307,  88           

45 U.S.C.A. 228;                                                   89           

      (5)  Add interest on federal, state, and local government    91           

obligations;                                                       92           

      (6)  For a person who received the homestead exemption for   94           

a prior year on the basis of being permanently and totally         95           

                                                          3      


                                                                 
disabled and whose current application for the exemption is made   96           

on the basis of age, subtract the following amount:                97           

      (a)  If the person received disability benefits that were    99           

not included in adjusted gross income in the year preceding the    100          

first year in which the person applied for the exemption on the    101          

basis of age, subtract an amount equal to the disability benefits  102          

the person received in that preceding year, to the extent          103          

included in total income in the current year and not subtracted    104          

under division (C)(1) of this section in the current year;         105          

      (b)  If the person received disability benefits that were    107          

included in adjusted gross income in the year preceding the first  108          

year in which the person applied for the exemption on the basis    109          

of age, subtract an amount equal to the amount of disability       110          

benefits that were subtracted pursuant to division (C)(1) of this  111          

section in that preceding year, to the extent included in total    112          

income in the current year and not subtracted under division                    

(C)(1) of this section in the current year.                        114          

      Disability benefits that are paid by the department of       116          

veterans affairs or a branch of the armed forces of the United     118          

States on account of an injury or disability shall not be          119          

included in total income.                                                       

      (D)  "Old age and survivors benefits received pursuant to    121          

the 'Social Security Act'" or "tier I railroad retirement          122          

benefits received pursuant to the 'Railroad Retirement Act'"       123          

means:                                                             124          

      (1)  For those persons receiving the homestead exemption     126          

for the first time for tax years 1976 and earlier, old age         127          

benefits payable under the social security or railroad retirement  128          

laws in effect on December 31, 1975, except in those cases where   129          

a change in social security or railroad retirement benefits would  130          

result in a reduction in income.                                   131          

      (2)  For those persons receiving the homestead exemption     133          

for the first time for tax years 1977 and thereafter, old age      134          

benefits payable under the social security or railroad retirement  135          

                                                          4      


                                                                 
laws in effect on the last day of the calendar year prior to the   136          

year for which the homestead exemption is first received, or, if   137          

no such benefits are payable that year, old age benefits payable   138          

the first succeeding year in which old age benefits under the      139          

social security or railroad retirement laws are payable, except    140          

in those cases where a change in social security or railroad       141          

retirement benefits results in a reduction in income.              142          

      (3)  The lesser of:                                          144          

      (a)  Survivors benefits payable under the social security    146          

or railroad retirement laws in effect on the last day of the       147          

calendar year prior to the year for which the homestead exemption  148          

is first received, or, if no such benefits are payable that year,  149          

survivors benefits payable the first succeeding year in which      150          

survivors benefits are payable; or                                 151          

      (b)  Old age benefits of the deceased spouse, as determined  153          

under division (D)(1) or (2) of this section, upon which the       154          

surviving spouse's survivors benefits are based under the social   155          

security or railroad retirement laws, except in those cases where  156          

a change in benefits would cause a reduction in income.            157          

      Survivors benefits are those described in division           159          

(D)(3)(b) of this section only if the deceased spouse received     160          

old age benefits in the year in which the deceased SPOUSE died.    161          

If the deceased spouse did not receive old age benefits in the     162          

year in which the deceased spouse died, then survivors benefits    163          

are those described in division (D)(3)(a) of this section.         164          

      (E)  "Permanently and totally disabled" means a person who   166          

has, on the first day of January of the year of application for    167          

reduction in real estate taxes, some impairment in body or mind    168          

that makes the person unfit to work at any substantially           169          

remunerative employment which THAT the person is reasonably able   171          

to perform and which THAT will, with reasonable probability,       174          

continue for an indefinite period of at least twelve months        175          

without any present indication of recovery therefrom or has been   176          

certified as permanently and totally disabled by a state or        177          

                                                          5      


                                                                 
federal agency having the function of so classifying persons.      178          

      (F)  "HOUSING COOPERATIVE" MEANS A HOUSING COMPLEX OF AT     180          

LEAST TWO HUNDRED FIFTY UNITS THAT IS OWNED AND OPERATED BY A      181          

NONPROFIT CORPORATION THAT ISSUES A SHARE OF THE CORPORATION'S     182          

STOCK TO AN INDIVIDUAL, ENTITLING THE INDIVIDUAL TO LIVE IN A      183          

UNIT OF THE COMPLEX, AND COLLECTS A MONTHLY MAINTENANCE FEE FROM   184          

THE INDIVIDUAL TO MAINTAIN, OPERATE, AND PAY THE TAXES OF THE      185          

COMPLEX.                                                                        

      Sec. 323.152.  In addition to the reduction in taxes         194          

required under section 319.302 of the Revised Code, taxes shall    195          

be reduced as provided in divisions (A) and (B) of this section.   197          

      (A)(1)  Division (A) of this section applies to any of the   200          

following:                                                                      

      (a)  A person who is permanently and totally disabled;       202          

      (b)  A person who is sixty-five years of age or older;       204          

      (c)  A person who is the surviving spouse of a deceased      206          

person who was permanently and totally disabled or sixty-five      207          

years of age or older and who applied and qualified for a          208          

reduction in taxes under this division in the year of death,       209          

provided the surviving spouse is at least fifty-nine but not       210          

sixty-five or more years of age on the date the deceased spouse    211          

dies.                                                                           

      (2)  Real property taxes on a homestead owned and occupied,  213          

OR A HOMESTEAD IN A HOUSING COOPERATIVE OCCUPIED, by a person to   215          

whom division (A) of this section applies shall be further         216          

reduced for each year for which the owner obtains a certificate    217          

of reduction from the county auditor under section 323.154 of the  218          

Revised Code OR FOR WHICH THE OCCUPANT OBTAINS A CERTIFICATE OF    219          

REDUCTION IN ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 323.159 OF THE REVISED CODE.  221          

The reduction shall equal the amount obtained by multiplying the   223          

tax rate for the tax year for which the certificate is issued by   224          

the reduction in taxable value shown in the following schedule:    225          

                                      Reduce Taxable Value         227          

       Total Income                    by the Lesser of:           229          

                                                          6      


                                                                 
$11,900 or less                 $5,000 or seventy-five per cent    232          

More than $11,900 but not       $3,000 or sixty per cent           234          

   more than $17,500                                                            

More than $17,500 but not       $1,000 or twenty-five per cent     236          

   more than $23,000                                                            

More than $23,000                              -0-                 238          

      (3)  Each calendar year beginning in 1999, the tax           242          

commissioner shall adjust the foregoing schedule by completing     243          

the following steps:                                                            

      (a)  Determine the percentage increase in the gross          245          

domestic product deflator determined by the bureau of economic     246          

analysis of the United States department of commerce from the      249          

first day of July of the preceding calendar year to the last day   250          

of June of the current calendar year;                              252          

      (b)  Multiply that percentage increase by each of the total  255          

income amounts, and by each dollar amount by which taxable value                

is reduced, for the current tax year;                              256          

      (c)  Add the resulting product to each of the total income   259          

amounts, and to each of the dollar amounts by which taxable value               

is reduced, for the current tax year;                              260          

      (d)  Round the resulting sum to the nearest multiple of one  263          

hundred dollars.                                                                

      The commissioner shall certify the amounts resulting from    265          

the adjustment to each county auditor not later than the first     266          

day of December each year.  The certified amounts apply to the     268          

following tax year.  The commissioner shall not make the           269          

adjustment in any calendar year in which the amounts resulting     270          

from the adjustment would be less than the total income amounts,   271          

or less than the dollar amounts by which taxable value is          272          

reduced, for the current tax year.                                              

      (B)  Real property taxes on any homestead, and manufactured  274          

home taxes on any manufactured or mobile home on which a           275          

manufactured home tax is assessed pursuant to division (D)(2) of   276          

section 4503.06 of the Revised Code, shall be reduced for each     277          

                                                          7      


                                                                 
year for which the owner obtains a certificate of reduction from   279          

the county auditor under section 323.154 of the Revised Code.      280          

The amount of the reduction shall equal one-fourth of the amount   281          

by which the taxes charged and payable on the homestead or the     282          

manufactured or mobile home are reduced for such year under        283          

section 319.302 of the Revised Code.                               284          

      (C)  The reductions granted by this section do not apply to  286          

special assessments or respread of assessments levied against the  287          

homestead, and if there is a transfer of ownership subsequent to   288          

the filing of an application for a reduction in taxes, such        289          

reductions are not forfeited for such year by virtue of such       290          

transfer.                                                          291          

      (D)  The reductions in taxable value referred to in this     293          

section shall be applied solely as a factor for the purpose of     294          

computing the reduction of taxes under this section and shall not  295          

affect the total value of property in any subdivision or taxing    296          

district as listed and assessed for taxation on the tax lists and  297          

duplicates, or any direct or indirect limitations on indebtedness  298          

of a subdivision or taxing district.  If after application of      299          

sections 5705.31 and 5705.32 of the Revised Code, including the    300          

allocation of all levies within the ten-mill limitation to debt    301          

charges to the extent therein provided, there would be             302          

insufficient funds for payment of debt charges not provided for    303          

by levies in excess of the ten-mill limitation, the reduction of   304          

taxes provided for in sections 323.151 to 323.157 323.159 of the   306          

Revised Code, shall be proportionately adjusted to the extent      307          

necessary to provide such funds from levies within the ten-mill    308          

limitation.                                                                     

      (E)  No reduction shall be made on the taxes due on the      310          

homestead of any person convicted of violating division (C) or     311          

(D) of section 323.153 of the Revised Code for a period of three   312          

years following the conviction.                                    313          

      Sec. 323.153.  (A)  To obtain a reduction in real property   324          

taxes under division (A) or (B) of section 323.152 of the Revised  325          

                                                          8      


                                                                 
Code or in manufactured home taxes under division (B) of section   326          

323.152 of the Revised Code, the owner shall file an application   327          

with the county auditor of the county in which the owner's         328          

homestead is located.                                                           

      TO OBTAIN A REDUCTION IN REAL PROPERTY TAXES UNDER DIVISION  330          

(A) OF SECTION 323.152 OF THE REVISED CODE, THE OCCUPANT OF A      331          

HOMESTEAD IN A HOUSING COOPERATIVE SHALL FILE AN APPLICATION WITH  333          

THE NONPROFIT CORPORATION THAT OWNS AND OPERATES THE HOUSING       334          

COOPERATIVE, IN ACCORDANCE WITH THIS PARAGRAPH.  NOT LATER THAN    335          

THE FIRST DAY OF MARCH EACH YEAR, THE CORPORATION SHALL OBTAIN     337          

APPLICATIONS FROM THE COUNTY AUDITOR'S OFFICE AND PROVIDE ONE TO   338          

EACH NEW OCCUPANT.  NOT LATER THAN THE FIRST DAY OF MAY, ANY       339          

OCCUPANT WHO MAY BE ELIGIBLE FOR A REDUCTION IN TAXES UNDER        341          

DIVISION (A) OF SECTION 323.152 OF THE REVISED CODE SHALL SUBMIT   342          

THE COMPLETED APPLICATION TO THE CORPORATION.  NOT LATER THAN THE  344          

FIFTEENTH DAY OF MAY, THE CORPORATION SHALL FILE ALL COMPLETED     346          

APPLICATIONS, AND THE INFORMATION REQUIRED BY DIVISION (B) OF      347          

SECTION 323.159 OF THE REVISED CODE, WITH THE COUNTY AUDITOR OF    349          

THE COUNTY IN WHICH THE OCCUPANTS' HOMESTEADS ARE LOCATED.                      

CONTINUING APPLICATIONS SHALL BE FURNISHED TO AN OCCUPANT IN THE   350          

MANNER PROVIDED IN DIVISION (C)(4) OF THIS SECTION.                352          

      (1)  An application for reduction based upon a physical      354          

disability shall be accompanied by a certificate signed by a       355          

physician, and an application for reduction based upon a mental    356          

disability shall be accompanied by a certificate signed by a       357          

physician or psychologist licensed to practice in this state,      358          

attesting to the fact that the applicant is permanently and        359          

totally disabled.  The certificate shall be in a form that the     360          

tax commissioner requires and shall include the definition of      361          

permanently and totally disabled as set forth in section 323.151   362          

of the Revised Code.  An application for reduction based upon a    363          

disability certified as permanent and total by a state or federal  364          

agency having the function of so classifying persons shall be      365          

accompanied by a certificate from that agency.  Such an            366          

                                                          9      


                                                                 
application constitutes a continuing application for a reduction   367          

in taxes for each year in which the dwelling is the applicant's    368          

homestead and the amount of the reduction in taxable value to      369          

which the applicant is entitled does not exceed either the amount  371          

or percentage of the reduction to which the applicant was          372          

entitled for the year in which the application was first filed.    374          

      (2)  An application for a reduction in taxes under division  376          

(B) of section 323.152 of the Revised Code shall be filed only if  378          

the homestead or manufactured or mobile home was transferred in    379          

the preceding year or did not qualify for and receive the          380          

reduction in taxes under that division for the preceding tax       381          

year.  The application for homesteads transferred in the           382          

preceding year shall be incorporated into any form used by the     384          

county auditor to administer the tax law in respect to the                      

conveyance of real property pursuant to section 319.20 of the      385          

Revised Code, and shall contain a statement that failure by the    387          

applicant to affirm on the application that the dwelling on the                 

property conveyed is the applicant's homestead prohibits the       388          

owner from receiving the reduction in taxes until a proper         389          

application is filed within the period prescribed by division      390          

(A)(3) of this section.  Such an application constitutes a         391          

continuing application for a reduction in taxes for each year in   392          

which the dwelling is the applicant's homestead.                                

      (3)  Failure to receive a new application filed under        394          

division (A)(1) or (2) or notification under division (C) of this  395          

section after a certificate of reduction has been issued under     396          

section 323.154 of the Revised Code, OR FAILURE TO RECEIVE A NEW   397          

APPLICATION FILED UNDER DIVISION (A)(1) OR NOTIFICATION UNDER      399          

DIVISION (C) OF THIS SECTION AFTER A CERTIFICATE OF REDUCTION HAS  400          

BEEN ISSUED UNDER SECTION 323.159 OF THE REVISED CODE, is          403          

prima-facie evidence that the original applicant is entitled to    404          

the reduction in taxes calculated on the basis of the information  405          

contained in the original application.  The original application   406          

and any subsequent application, including any late application,    407          

                                                          10     


                                                                 
shall be in the form of a signed statement and shall be filed      408          

after the first Monday in January and not later than the first     409          

Monday in June.  The original application and any subsequent       410          

application for a reduction in real property taxes shall be filed  411          

in the year for which the reduction is sought.  The original       412          

application and any subsequent application for a reduction in      413          

manufactured home taxes shall be filed in the year preceding the                

year for which the reduction is sought.  The statement shall be    414          

on a form, devised and supplied by the tax commissioner, which     416          

shall require no more information than is necessary to establish   417          

the applicant's eligibility for the reduction in taxes and the     418          

amount of the reduction, and, FOR A CERTIFICATE OF REDUCTION       419          

ISSUED UNDER SECTION 323.154 OF THE REVISED CODE, shall include    421          

an affirmation by the applicant that ownership of the homestead    422          

was not acquired from a person, other than a the applicant's                    

spouse, related to the owner by consanguinity or affinity for the  423          

purpose of qualifying for the real property or manufactured home   424          

tax reduction provided for in division (A) or (B) of section       425          

323.152 of the Revised Code.  The form shall contain a statement   426          

that conviction of willfully falsifying information to obtain a    427          

reduction in taxes or failing to comply with division (C) of this  428          

section results in the revocation of the right to the reduction    429          

for a period of three years.  In the case of an application for a  430          

reduction in taxes under division (A) of section 323.152 of the    431          

Revised Code, the form shall contain a statement that signing the  432          

application constitutes a delegation of authority by the           433          

applicant to the county auditor to examine any financial records   434          

relating to income earned by the applicant as stated on the        435          

application for the purpose of determining a possible violation    436          

of division (D) or (E) of this section.                            437          

      (B)  A late application for a tax reduction for the year     439          

preceding the year in which an original application is filed, or   440          

for a reduction in manufactured home taxes for the year in which   441          

an original application is filed, may be filed with the original   442          

                                                          11     


                                                                 
application.  If the county auditor determines the information     444          

contained in the late application is correct, the auditor shall    445          

determine the amount of the reduction in taxes to which the        446          

applicant would have been entitled for the preceding tax year had  447          

the applicant's application been timely filed and approved in      448          

that year.                                                                      

      The amount of such reduction shall be treated by the         450          

auditor as an overpayment of taxes by the applicant and shall be   451          

refunded in the manner prescribed in section 5715.22 of the        452          

Revised Code for making refunds of overpayments.  On the first     453          

day of July of each year, the county auditor shall certify the     454          

total amount of the reductions in taxes made in the current year   455          

under this division to the tax commissioner, who shall treat the   456          

full amount thereof as a reduction in taxes for the preceding tax  457          

year and shall make reimbursement to the county therefor in the    458          

manner prescribed by section 323.156 of the Revised Code, from     459          

money appropriated for that purpose.                               460          

      (C)(1)  If, in any year after an application has been filed  462          

under division (A)(1) or (2) of this section, the owner does not   464          

qualify for a reduction in taxes on the homestead or on the                     

manufactured or mobile home set forth on such application, or      466          

qualifies for a reduction in taxes that is to be based upon a      467          

reduction in taxable value less than either the percentage or      468          

amount of the reduction in taxable value to which the owner was    469          

entitled in the year the application was filed, the owner shall    470          

notify the county auditor that the owner is not qualified for a    471          

reduction in taxes or file a new application under division        472          

(A)(1) or (2) of this section.  If                                 473          

      (2)  IF, IN ANY YEAR AFTER AN APPLICATION HAS BEEN FILED     475          

UNDER DIVISION (A)(1) OF THIS SECTION, THE OCCUPANT OF A           476          

HOMESTEAD IN A HOUSING COOPERATIVE DOES NOT QUALIFY FOR A          477          

REDUCTION IN TAXES ON THE HOMESTEAD, THE OCCUPANT SHALL NOTIFY     479          

THE COUNTY AUDITOR THAT THE OCCUPANT IS NOT QUALIFIED FOR A                     

REDUCTION IN TAXES OR FILE A NEW APPLICATION UNDER DIVISION        481          

                                                          12     


                                                                 
(A)(1) OF THIS SECTION.                                                         

      (3)  IF the county auditor or county treasurer discovers     483          

that the owner of property not entitled to the reduction in taxes  484          

under division (B) of section 323.152 of the Revised Code failed   486          

to notify the county auditor as required by this paragraph         487          

DIVISION (C)(1) OF THIS SECTION, a charge shall be imposed         489          

against the property in the amount by which taxes were reduced     490          

under that division for each tax year the county auditor                        

ascertains that the property was not entitled to the reduction     491          

and was owned by the current owner.  Interest shall accrue in the  492          

manner prescribed by division (B) of section 323.121 of the        494          

Revised Code on the amount by which taxes were reduced for each    495          

such tax year as if the reduction became delinquent taxes at the   496          

close of the last day the second installment of taxes for that                  

tax year could be paid without penalty.  The county auditor shall  498          

notify the owner, by ordinary mail, of the charge, of the owner's  499          

right to appeal the charge, and of the manner in which the owner   500          

may appeal.  The owner may appeal the imposition of the charge     501          

and interest by filing an appeal with the county board of          502          

revision not later than the last day prescribed for payment of     503          

real and public utility property taxes under section 323.12 of     504          

the Revised Code following receipt of the notice and occurring at  506          

least ninety days after receipt of the notice.  The appeal shall   507          

be treated in the same manner as a complaint relating to the       508          

valuation or assessment of real property under Chapter 5715. of    509          

the Revised Code.  The charge and any interest shall be collected  511          

as other delinquent taxes.                                                      

      (4)  Each year during January, the county auditor shall      513          

furnish by ordinary mail a continuing application to each person   514          

issued a certificate of reduction under section 323.154 OR         515          

323.159 of the Revised Code with respect to a reduction in taxes   517          

under division (A) of section 323.152 of the Revised Code.  The    518          

continuing application shall be used to report changes in total    519          

income that would have the effect of increasing or decreasing the  520          

                                                          13     


                                                                 
reduction in taxable value to which the owner PERSON is entitled,  521          

changes in ownership OR OCCUPANCY of the homestead, including      523          

changes in or revocation of a revocable inter vivos trust,         524          

changes in disability, and other changes in the information        525          

earlier furnished the auditor relative to the reduction in taxes   526          

on the property.  The continuing application shall be returned to  527          

the auditor not later than the first Monday in June; provided,     528          

that if such changes do not affect the status of the homestead     529          

exemption or the amount of the reduction to which the owner is     530          

entitled under division (A) of section 323.152 of the Revised      531          

Code OR TO WHICH THE OCCUPANT IS ENTITLED UNDER SECTION 323.159    532          

OF THE REVISED CODE, the application does not need to be           534          

returned.                                                          535          

      (5)  Each year during February, the county auditor, except   537          

as otherwise provided in this paragraph, shall furnish by          540          

ordinary mail an original application to the owner, as of the                   

first day of January of that year, of a homestead or a             541          

manufactured or mobile home that transferred during the preceding  542          

calendar year and that qualified for and received a reduction in   543          

taxes under division (B) of section 323.152 of the Revised Code    544          

for the preceding tax year.  In order to receive the reduction     545          

under that division, the owner shall file the application with     546          

the county auditor not later than the first Monday in June.  If    547          

the application is not timely filed, the auditor shall not grant   548          

a reduction in taxes for the homestead for the current year, and   549          

shall notify the owner that the reduction in taxes has not been    550          

granted, in the same manner prescribed under section 323.154 of    551          

the Revised Code for notification of denial of an application.     552          

Failure of an owner to receive an application does not excuse the  553          

failure of the owner to file an original application.  The county  555          

auditor is not required to furnish an application under this       556          

paragraph for any homestead for which application has previously   557          

been made on a form incorporated into any form used by the county  558          

auditor to administer the tax law in respect to the conveyance of  559          

                                                          14     


                                                                 
real property, and an owner who previously has applied on such a   560          

form is not required to return an application furnished under      561          

this paragraph.                                                                 

      (D)  No person shall knowingly make a false statement for    563          

the purpose of obtaining a reduction in the person's real          564          

property or manufactured home taxes under section 323.152 of the   565          

Revised Code.                                                                   

      (E)  No person shall knowingly fail to notify the county     567          

auditor of changes required by division (C) of this section that   568          

have the effect of maintaining or securing a reduction in taxable  569          

value of homestead property or a reduction in taxes in excess of   570          

the reduction allowed under section 323.152 of the Revised Code.   571          

      (F)  No person shall knowingly make a false statement or     573          

certification attesting to any person's physical or mental         574          

condition for purposes of qualifying such person for tax relief    575          

pursuant to sections 323.151 to 323.157 323.159 of the Revised     576          

Code.                                                              577          

      Sec. 323.154.  On or before the day the county auditor has   586          

completed the duties imposed by sections 319.30 to 319.302 of the  587          

Revised Code, the auditor shall issue a certificate of reduction   589          

in taxes in triplicate for each person who has complied with       590          

section 323.153 of the Revised Code and whose homestead, AS                     

DEFINED IN DIVISION (A)(1) OF SECTION 323.151 OF THE REVISED       592          

CODE, or manufactured or mobile home the auditor finds is          594          

entitled to a reduction in real property or manufactured home                   

taxes for that year under section 323.152 of the Revised Code.     596          

In EXCEPT AS PROVIDED IN SECTION 323.159 OF THE REVISED CODE, IN   597          

the case of a homestead entitled to a reduction under division     598          

(A) of that section, the certificate shall state the taxable       599          

value of the homestead on the first day of January of that year,   600          

the amount of the reduction in taxable value and the total         601          

reduction in taxes for that year under that section, the tax rate  602          

that is applicable against such homestead for that year, and any   603          

other information the tax commissioner requires.  In the case of   604          

                                                          15     


                                                                 
a homestead or a manufactured or mobile home entitled to a         605          

reduction under division (B) of that section, the certificate      607          

shall state the total amount of the reduction in taxes for that    608          

year under that section and any other information the tax          609          

commissioner requires.  The certificate for reduction in taxes     610          

shall be on a form approved by the commissioner.  Upon issuance    611          

of such a certificate, the county auditor shall forward one copy   612          

and the original to the county treasurer and retain one copy.      613          

The county auditor ALSO shall also record the amount of reduction  614          

in taxes in the appropriate column on the general tax list and     615          

duplicate of real and public utility property and on the                        

manufactured home tax list.                                        616          

      If an application, late application, or continuing           618          

application is not approved, or if the county auditor otherwise    619          

determines that a homestead or a manufactured or mobile home does  620          

not qualify for a reduction in taxes under division (A) or (B) of  622          

section 323.152 of the Revised Code, the auditor shall notify the  623          

applicant of the reasons for denial not later than the first       624          

Monday in October.  If an applicant believes that the application  625          

for reduction has been improperly denied or that the reduction is  627          

for less than that to which the applicant is entitled, the         628          

applicant may file an appeal with the county board of revision     629          

not later than the date of closing of the collection for the       630          

first half of real and public utility property taxes or            631          

manufactured home taxes.  The appeal shall be treated in the same  633          

manner as a complaint relating to the valuation or assessment of   634          

real property under Chapter 5715. of the Revised Code.             635          

      Sec. 323.155.  The county treasurer shall retain the         644          

original certificate of reduction in taxes ISSUED UNDER SECTION    645          

323.154 OF THE REVISED CODE and forward the copy to the person to  646          

whom the certificate is issued, along with the tax bill submitted  647          

pursuant to section 323.13 of the Revised Code or the advance      649          

payment certificate submitted pursuant to section 4503.061 of the  650          

Revised Code.  Such                                                             

                                                          16     


                                                                 
      THE COUNTY TREASURER SHALL RETAIN THE ORIGINAL CERTIFICATE   652          

OF REDUCTION ISSUED UNDER SECTION 323.159 OF THE REVISED CODE AND  654          

FORWARD A COPY TO THE PERSON TO WHOM THE CERTIFICATE IS ISSUED,    655          

AND A COPY TO THE NONPROFIT CORPORATION THAT OWNS AND OPERATES     656          

THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE IN WHICH THE PERSON IS AN OCCUPANT, ALONG  657          

WITH THE CORPORATION'S TAX BILL SUBMITTED PURSUANT TO SECTION      658          

323.13 OF THE REVISED CODE.                                        659          

      THE tax bill shall indicate the net amount of taxes due      662          

following the reductions in taxes under sections 319.301,                       

319.302, and 323.152 of the Revised Code.                          663          

      Any reduction in taxes under this section shall be           665          

disregarded as income or resources in determining eligibility for  666          

any program or calculating any payment under Title LI of the       667          

Revised Code.                                                                   

      Sec. 323.156.  Within thirty days after a settlement of      676          

taxes under divisions (A) and (C) of section 321.24 of the         677          

Revised Code, the county treasurer shall certify to the tax        678          

commissioner one-half of the total amount of taxes on real         679          

property that were reduced pursuant to section 323.152 of the      680          

Revised Code for the preceding tax year, and one-half of the       681          

total amount of taxes on manufactured and mobile homes that were   682          

reduced pursuant to division (B) of section 323.152 of the         683          

Revised Code for the current tax year, as evidenced by the         685          

certificates of reduction and the tax duplicate certified to the   686          

county treasurer by the county auditor.  The commissioner, within  688          

thirty days of the receipt of such certification, shall provide    689          

for payment to the county treasurer, from the general revenue      690          

fund, of the amount certified, which shall be credited upon        691          

receipt to the county's undivided income tax fund, and an amount   692          

equal to two per cent of the amount by which taxes were reduced,   693          

which shall be credited upon receipt to the county general fund    694          

as a payment, in addition to the fees and charges authorized by    695          

sections 319.54 and 321.26 of the Revised Code, to the county      696          

auditor and treasurer for the costs of administering the           697          

                                                          17     


                                                                 
exemption provided under sections 323.151 to 323.157 323.159 of    698          

the Revised Code.                                                               

      Immediately upon receipt of funds into the county undivided  700          

income tax fund under this section, the auditor shall distribute   701          

the full amount thereof among the taxing districts in the county   702          

as though the total had been paid as taxes by each person for      703          

whom taxes were reduced under sections 323.151 to 323.157 323.159  705          

of the Revised Code.                                               706          

      Sec. 323.157.  Each county treasurer and county auditor      715          

shall employ the assistants, clerks, and other employees           716          

necessary to carry out the duties imposed by sections 323.151 to   717          

323.157 323.159 of the Revised Code.  The tax commissioner shall   719          

promulgate rules necessary to facilitate the reduction of taxes    720          

on homesteads, reimbursement by the state, the determination of                 

"total income," and the administration of sections 323.151 to      721          

323.157 323.159 of the Revised Code.                               723          

      Sec. 323.159.  (A)  AS USED IN THIS SECTION:                 725          

      (1)  "APPLICANT" MEANS THE PERSON WHO OCCUPIES A HOMESTEAD   727          

IN A HOUSING COOPERATIVE.                                          728          

      (2)  "HOMESTEAD" HAS THE SAME MEANING AS IN DIVISION (A)(2)  730          

OF SECTION 323.151 OF THE REVISED CODE.                            731          

      (B)  NOT LATER THAN THE FIRST DAY OF MAY EACH YEAR, ANY      733          

NONPROFIT CORPORATION THAT OWNS AND OPERATES A HOUSING             735          

COOPERATIVE SHALL DETERMINE THE AMOUNT OF PROPERTY TAXES IT PAID   736          

FOR THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE FOR THE PRECEDING TAX YEAR AND SHALL   737          

ATTRIBUTE TO EACH HOMESTEAD IN THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE A PORTION   738          

OF THE TOTAL PROPERTY TAXES AS IF THE HOMESTEAD'S OCCUPANT PAID    739          

THE TAXES.  THE TAXES ATTRIBUTED TO EACH HOMESTEAD SHALL BE BASED  740          

ON THE PERCENTAGE THAT THE SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE HOMESTEAD IS OF   741          

THE TOTAL SQUARE FOOTAGE OF THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE AND ON OTHER   742          

REASONABLE FACTORS THAT REFLECT THE VALUE OF THE HOMESTEAD.  NOT   743          

LATER THAN THE FIFTEENTH DAY OF MAY EACH YEAR, THE CORPORATION     744          

SHALL FILE THIS INFORMATION WITH THE COUNTY AUDITOR, ALONG WITH    745          

ANY APPLICATIONS SUBMITTED TO IT UNDER DIVISION (A) OF SECTION     746          

                                                          18     


                                                                 
323.153 OF THE REVISED CODE.  NO NONPROFIT CORPORATION THAT OWNS   747          

AND OPERATES A HOUSING COOPERATIVE SHALL FAIL TO FILE WITH THE     748          

COUNTY AUDITOR THE INFORMATION REQUIRED BY THIS DIVISION AND       749          

DIVISION (A) OF SECTION 323.153 OF THE REVISED CODE.               750          

      (C)  ON OR BEFORE THE DAY THE COUNTY AUDITOR HAS COMPLETED   752          

THE DUTIES IMPOSED BY SECTIONS 319.30 TO 319.302 OF THE REVISED    754          

CODE, THE AUDITOR SHALL ISSUE A CERTIFICATE OF REDUCTION IN TAXES  755          

FOR EACH APPLICANT WHO HAS COMPLIED WITH SECTION 323.153 OF THE    757          

REVISED CODE AND WHOSE HOMESTEAD THE AUDITOR FINDS IS ENTITLED TO  758          

A REDUCTION IN REAL PROPERTY TAXES FOR THAT YEAR UNDER DIVISION    759          

(A) OF SECTION 323.152 OF THE REVISED CODE.  THE COUNTY AUDITOR    760          

SHALL CALCULATE THE TAXABLE VALUE OF EACH APPLICANT'S HOMESTEAD    762          

AS IF THE HOMESTEAD WAS OWNED BY THE APPLICANT AND SHALL USE THE   763          

INFORMATION PROVIDED BY THE NONPROFIT CORPORATION UNDER DIVISION   764          

(B) OF THIS SECTION TO DETERMINE THE REDUCTION IN TAXABLE VALUE    765          

TO BE ATTRIBUTED TO THE HOMESTEAD.                                 766          

      THE CERTIFICATE SHALL STATE THE TAXABLE VALUE, ON THE FIRST  768          

DAY OF JANUARY OF THAT YEAR, ATTRIBUTED TO EACH HOMESTEAD IN THE   769          

HOUSING COOPERATIVE; THE REDUCTION IN TAXABLE VALUE AND REDUCTION  770          

IN TAXES ATTRIBUTED TO THE HOMESTEAD; THE TOTAL AMOUNT OF THE      772          

REDUCTION IN TAXABLE VALUE FOR THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE BASED ON    773          

ALL CERTIFICATES ISSUED UNDER THIS SECTION FOR HOMESTEADS IN THE   774          

HOUSING COOPERATIVE; THE NONPROFIT CORPORATION'S TOTAL REDUCTION   775          

IN TAXES FOR THAT YEAR UNDER DIVISION (A) OF SECTION 323.152 OF    776          

THE REVISED CODE; THE TAX RATE THAT IS APPLICABLE AGAINST THE      778          

HOUSING COOPERATIVE FOR THAT YEAR; AND ANY OTHER INFORMATION THE   779          

TAX COMMISSIONER REQUIRES.  THE COUNTY AUDITOR SHALL PREPARE       780          

THREE COPIES OF THE ORIGINAL CERTIFICATE.  UPON THE ISSUANCE OF                 

SUCH A CERTIFICATE, THE COUNTY AUDITOR SHALL FORWARD TWO COPIES    781          

AND THE ORIGINAL TO THE COUNTY TREASURER AND RETAIN ONE COPY.      782          

THE COUNTY AUDITOR ALSO SHALL RECORD THE AMOUNT OF REDUCTION IN    783          

TAXES IN THE APPROPRIATE COLUMN ON THE GENERAL TAX LIST AND        784          

DUPLICATE OF REAL AND PUBLIC UTILITY PROPERTY.                     785          

      (D)  ON RECEIPT OF THE NOTICE FROM THE COUNTY AUDITOR UNDER  787          

                                                          19     


                                                                 
DIVISION (C) OF THIS SECTION, THE NONPROFIT CORPORATION THAT OWNS  788          

AND OPERATES THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE SHALL REDUCE THE MONTHLY      789          

MAINTENANCE FEE FOR EACH HOMESTEAD FOR WHICH AN APPLICANT          791          

RECEIVED A CERTIFICATE OF REDUCTION UNDER THIS SECTION FOR THE     792          

YEAR FOLLOWING THE YEAR FOR WHICH THE CERTIFICATE WAS ISSUED.      793          

THE REDUCTION IN THE MONTHLY MAINTENANCE FEE SHALL EQUAL           794          

ONE-TWELFTH OF THE REDUCTION IN TAXES ATTRIBUTED TO THE HOMESTEAD  795          

BY THE COUNTY AUDITOR UNDER DIVISION (C) OF THIS SECTION.          796          

      (E)  IF AN APPLICATION, LATE APPLICATION, OR CONTINUING      798          

APPLICATION IS NOT APPROVED, OR IF THE COUNTY AUDITOR OTHERWISE    799          

DETERMINES THAT A HOMESTEAD DOES NOT QUALIFY FOR A REDUCTION IN    800          

TAXES UNDER DIVISION (A) OF SECTION 323.152 OF THE REVISED CODE,   802          

THE AUDITOR SHALL NOTIFY THE APPLICANT, AND THE NONPROFIT          803          

CORPORATION THAT OWNS AND OPERATES THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE, OF     805          

THE REASONS FOR DENIAL NOT LATER THAN THE FIRST MONDAY IN          807          

OCTOBER.  IF THE APPLICANT BELIEVES THAT THE APPLICATION FOR       808          

REDUCTION HAS BEEN IMPROPERLY DENIED, OR THE NONPROFIT                          

CORPORATION THAT OWNS AND OPERATES THE HOUSING COOPERATIVE         809          

BELIEVES THAT THE REDUCTION IS FOR LESS THAN THAT TO WHICH THE     810          

HOUSING COOPERATIVE IS ENTITLED, THE APPLICANT OR HOUSING          811          

COOPERATIVE, RESPECTIVELY, MAY FILE AN APPEAL WITH THE COUNTY      812          

BOARD OF REVISION NOT LATER THAN THE DATE OF CLOSING OF THE        813          

COLLECTION FOR THE FIRST HALF OF REAL AND PUBLIC UTILITY PROPERTY  814          

TAXES.  THE APPEAL SHALL BE TREATED IN THE SAME MANNER AS A        815          

COMPLAINT RELATING TO THE VALUATION OR ASSESSMENT OF REAL          816          

PROPERTY UNDER CHAPTER 5715. OF THE REVISED CODE.                  817          

      Sec. 323.99.  Whoever violates division (D), (E), or (F) of  826          

section 323.153 OR DIVISION (B) OF SECTION 323.159 of the Revised  828          

Code is guilty of a misdemeanor of the fourth degree.                           

      Sec. 5715.30.  The tax commissioner shall prescribe for and  837          

furnish to all county boards of revision, county auditors, and     838          

county treasurers blank forms for all oaths of office,             839          

statements, returns, reports, tax lists and duplicates,            840          

abstracts, records of proceedings, complaints, notices of appeal,  841          

                                                          20     


                                                                 
tax bills, receipts, and all other documents, files, and records   842          

authorized or required by any law which relates to the             843          

assessment, levy, or collection of taxes or the reduction of       844          

taxes or by any rules, orders, or instructions of the              845          

commissioner.  The commissioner shall prescribe a form for tax     846          

lists and duplicates to insure proper administration of sections   847          

319.301, 319.302, and 323.151 to 323.157 323.159 of the Revised    849          

Code.  The commissioner shall prescribe and furnish blank forms    850          

of records and papers for all proceedings and official actions     851          

authorized or required by any law which relates to the             852          

assessment, levy, or collection of taxes or by any rules, orders,  853          

or instruction of the commissioner.  Auditors, treasurers, all     854          

other officers, and all persons required to list property for      855          

taxation shall use true copies of such blank forms.                856          

      Section  2.  That existing sections 323.151, 323.152,        858          

323.153, 323.154, 323.155, 323.156, 323.157, 323.99, and 5715.30   859          

of the Revised Code are hereby repealed.                           860          

      Section 3.  Section 323.153 of the Revised Code is           862          

presented in this act as a composite of the section as amended by  863          

Am. Sub. H.B. 177, Am. Sub. S.B. 201, and Am. Sub. S.B. 142, all   864          

of the 122nd General Assembly, with the new language of none of    866          

the acts shown in capital letters.  This is in recognition of the  867          

principle stated in division (B) of section 1.52 of the Revised    868          

Code that such amendments are to be harmonized where not           869          

substantively irreconcilable and constitutes a legislative         870          

finding that such is the resulting version in effect prior to the  871          

effective date of this act.