As Passed by the Senate

128th General Assembly
Regular Session
2009-2010
Sub. H. B. No. 363


Representatives Okey, Newcomb 

Cosponsors: Representatives Evans, Adams, J., Harwood, Yuko, Amstutz, Bacon, Blessing, Bolon, Boose, Coley, Combs, Daniels, Derickson, Dyer, Garland, Grossman, Hackett, Heard, Letson, Luckie, McClain, Oelslager, Ruhl, Snitchler, Weddington, Zehringer 

Senators Schuring, Gibbs, Faber, Grendell, Buehrer, Gillmor, Sawyer, Schaffer, Widener, Wilson, Harris, Hughes, Cates 



A BILL
To amend sections 903.01, 903.02, 903.03, 903.04, 1
903.05, 903.06, 903.07, 903.08, 903.081, 903.082, 2
903.09, 903.10, 903.15, 903.16, 903.17, and 3
6111.03 of the Revised Code, and to amend Section 4
640.24 of Am. Sub. H.B. 1 of the 128th General 5
Assembly and Sections 120.01 and 120.02 of Am. 6
Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th General Assembly, as 7
amended by Am. Sub. H.B. 1 of the 128th General 8
Assembly, to revise the Concentrated Animal 9
Feeding Facilities Law, to specify that certain 10
provisions amended by this act do not become 11
operative until the Administrator of the United 12
States Environmental Protection Agency approves 13
the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination 14
System program submitted by the Director of 15
Agriculture, to extend from January 1, 2010, to 16
July 1, 2010, the termination date of the 17
suspension of statutes and temporary law governing 18
sewage treatment systems that were enacted by Am. 19
Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th General Assembly and 20
subsequently amended and reenacted by Am. Sub. 21
H.B. 1 of the 128th General Assembly, and to 22
declare an emergency.23


BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF OHIO:

       Section 1. That sections 903.01, 903.02, 903.03, 903.04, 24
903.05, 903.06, 903.07, 903.08, 903.081, 903.082, 903.09, 903.10, 25
903.15, 903.16, 903.17, and 6111.03 of the Revised Code be amended 26
to read as follows:27

       Sec. 903.01.  As used in this chapter: 28

       (A) "Agricultural animal" means any animal generally used for 29
food or in the production of food, including cattle, sheep, goats, 30
rabbits, poultry, and swine; horses; alpacas; llamas; and any 31
other animal included by the director of agriculture by rule. 32
"Agricultural animal" does not include fish or other aquatic 33
animals regardless of whether they are raised at fish hatcheries, 34
fish farms, or other facilities that raise aquatic animals. 35

       (B) "Animal feeding facility" means a lot, building, or 36
structure where both of the following conditions are met: 37

       (1) Agricultural animals have been, are, or will be stabled 38
or confined and fed or maintained there for a total of forty-five 39
days or more in any twelve-month period. 40

       (2) Crops, vegetative forage growth, or post-harvest residues 41
are not sustained in the normal growing season over any portion of 42
the lot, building, or structure. 43

       "Animal feeding facility" also includes land that is owned or 44
leased by or otherwise is under the control of the owner or 45
operator of the lot, building, or structure and on which manure 46
originating from agricultural animals in the lot, building, or 47
structure or a production area is or may be applied. 48

       Two or more animal feeding facilities under common ownership 49
shall be considered to be a single animal feeding facility for the 50
purposes of this chapter if they adjoin each other or if they use 51
a common area or system for the disposal of manure. 52

       (C) "Best management practices" means best management 53
practices established in rules.Animal feeding operation" has the 54
same meaning as "animal feeding facility."55

       (D) "Cattle" includes, but is not limited to, heifers, 56
steers, bulls, and cow and calf pairs. 57

       (E) "Concentrated animal feeding facility" means an animal 58
feeding facility with a total design capacity equal to or more 59
than the number of animals specified in any of the categories in 60
division (M) of this section. 61

       (F) "Concentrated animal feeding operation" means an animal 62
feeding facility that complies with one of the following: 63

       (1) Has a total design capacity equal to or more than the 64
number of animals specified in any of the categories in division 65
(M) of this section; 66

       (2) Satisfies the criteria in division (M), (Q), or (EE)(FF)67
of this section; 68

       (3) Is designated by the director of agriculture as a medium 69
or small concentrated animal feeding operation pursuant to rules. 70

       (G) "Discharge" means to add from a point source to waters of 71
the state. 72

       (H) "Federal Water Pollution Control Act" means the "Federal 73
Water Pollution Control Act Amendments of 1972," 86 Stat. 816, 33 74
U.S.C. 1251 et. seq., as amended, and regulations adopted under 75
it. 76

       (I) "Finalized," with respect to the programs required under 77
division (A)(1) of section 903.02 and division (A)(1) of section 78
903.03 of the Revised Code, means that all rules that are 79
necessary for the administration of this chapter have been adopted 80
and all employees of the department of agriculture that are 81
necessary for the administration of this chapter have been 82
employed. 83

       (J) "General permit" has the meaning that is established in 84
rules. 85

       (K) "Individual permit" has the meaning that is established 86
in rules. 87

       (L) "Installation permit" means a permit for the installation 88
or modification of a disposal system or any part of a disposal 89
system issued by the director of environmental protection under 90
division (J)(1) of section 6111.03 of the Revised Code. 91

       (M) "Large concentrated animal feeding operation" means an 92
animal feeding facility that stables or confines at least the 93
number of animals specified in any of the following categories: 94

        (1) Seven hundred mature dairy cattle whether milked or dry; 95

        (2) One thousand veal calves; 96

        (3) One thousand cattle other than mature dairy cattle or 97
veal calves; 98

        (4) Two thousand five hundred swine that each weigh 99
fifty-five pounds or more; 100

        (5) Ten thousand swine that each weigh less than fifty-five 101
pounds; 102

        (6) Five hundred horses; 103

        (7) Ten thousand sheep or lambs; 104

        (8) Fifty-five thousand turkeys; 105

        (9) Thirty thousand laying hens or broilers if the animal 106
feeding facility uses a liquid manure handling system; 107

        (10) One hundred twenty-five thousand chickens, other than 108
laying hens, if the animal feeding facility uses a manure handling 109
system that is not a liquid manure handling system; 110

        (11) Eighty-two thousand laying hens if the animal feeding 111
facility uses a manure handling system that is not a liquid manure 112
handling system; 113

        (12) Thirty thousand ducks if the animal feeding facility 114
uses a manure handling system that is not a liquid manure handling 115
system; 116

        (13) Five thousand ducks if the animal feeding facility uses 117
a liquid manure handling system. 118

       (N) "Major concentrated animal feeding facility" means a 119
concentrated animal feeding facility with a total design capacity 120
of more than ten times the number of animals specified in any of 121
the categories in division (M) of this section. 122

       (O) "Manure" means any of the following wastes used in or 123
resulting from the production of agricultural animals or direct 124
agricultural products such as milk or eggs: animal excreta, 125
discarded products, bedding, process waste water, process 126
generated waste water, waste feed, silage drainage, and compost 127
products resulting from mortality composting or the composting of 128
animal excreta. 129

       (P) "Manure storage or treatment facility" means any 130
excavated, diked, or walled structure or combination of structures 131
designed for the biological stabilization, holding, or storage of 132
manure. 133

       (Q) "Medium concentrated animal feeding operation" means an 134
animal feeding facility that satisfies both of the following: 135

        (1) The facility stables or confines the number of animals 136
specified in any of the following categories: 137

        (a) Two hundred to six hundred ninety-nine mature dairy 138
cattle whether milked or dry; 139

        (b) Three hundred to nine hundred ninety-nine veal calves; 140

        (c) Three hundred to nine hundred ninety-nine cattle other 141
than mature dairy cattle or veal calves; 142

        (d) Seven hundred fifty to two thousand four hundred 143
ninety-nine swine that each weigh fifty-five pounds or more; 144

        (e) Three thousand to nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine 145
swine that each weigh less than fifty-five pounds; 146

        (f) One hundred fifty to four hundred ninety-nine horses; 147

        (g) Three thousand to nine thousand nine hundred ninety-nine 148
sheep or lambs; 149

        (h) Sixteen thousand five hundred to fifty-four thousand nine 150
hundred ninety-nine turkeys; 151

        (i) Nine thousand to twenty-nine thousand nine hundred 152
ninety-nine laying hens or broilers if the animal feeding facility 153
uses a liquid manure handling system; 154

        (j) Thirty-seven thousand five hundred to one hundred 155
twenty-four thousand nine hundred ninety-nine chickens, other than 156
laying hens, if the animal feeding facility uses a manure handling 157
system that is not a liquid manure handling system; 158

        (k) Twenty-five thousand to eighty-one thousand nine hundred 159
ninety-nine laying hens if the animal feeding facility uses a 160
manure handling system that is not a liquid manure handling 161
system; 162

        (l) Ten thousand to twenty-nine thousand nine hundred 163
ninety-nine ducks if the animal feeding facility uses a manure 164
handling system that is not a liquid manure handling system; 165

        (m) One thousand five hundred to four thousand nine hundred 166
ninety-nine ducks if the animal feeding facility uses a liquid 167
manure handling system. 168

        (2) The facility does one of the following: 169

        (a) Discharges pollutants into waters of the United States 170
through a ditch constructed by humans, a flushing system 171
constructed by humans, or another similar device constructed by 172
humans; 173

        (b) Discharges pollutants directly into waters of the United 174
States that originate outside of and that pass over, across, or 175
through the facility or otherwise come into direct contact with 176
the animals at the facility. 177

        "Medium concentrated animal feeding operation" includes an 178
animal feeding facility that is designated by the director as a 179
medium concentrated animal feeding operation pursuant to rules. 180

        (R) "Mortality composting" means the controlled decomposition 181
of organic solid material consisting of dead animals that 182
stabilizes the organic fraction of the material. 183

       (S) "NPDES permit" means a permit issued under the national 184
pollutant discharge elimination system established in section 402 185
of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and includes the 186
renewal of such a permit. "NPDES permit" includes the federally 187
enforceable provisions of a permit to operate into which NPDES 188
permit provisions have been incorporated. 189

       (T) "Permit" includes an initial, renewed, or modified permit 190
to install, permit to operate, NPDES permit, and installation 191
permit unless expressly stated otherwise. 192

       (U) "Permit to install" means a permit issued under section 193
903.02 of the Revised Code. 194

       (V) "Permit to operate" means a permit issued or renewed 195
under section 903.03 of the Revised Code and includes incorporated 196
NPDES permit provisions, if applicable. 197

       (W) "Person" means any legal entity defined as a person under198
has the same meaning as in section 1.59 of the Revised Code,and 199
also includes the state, any political subdivision of the state, 200
any interstate body created by compact, the United States, or any 201
department, agency, or instrumentality of any of those entities. 202

       (X) "Point source" has the same meaning as in the Federal 203
Water Pollution Control Act. 204

       (Y) "Pollutant" means dredged spoil, solid waste, incinerator 205
residue, filter backwash, sewage, garbage, sewage sludge, 206
munitions, chemical wastes, biological materials, radioactive 207
materials except those regulated under the "Atomic Energy Act of 208
1954," 68 Stat. 919, 42 U.S.C. 2011, as amended, heat, wrecked or 209
discarded equipment, rock, sand, cellar dirt, and industrial, 210
municipal, and agricultural waste, including manure, discharged 211
into water. "Pollutant" does not include either of the following:212

       (1) Sewage from vessels;213

       (2) Water, gas, or other material that is injected into a 214
well to facilitate production of oil or gas, or water derived in 215
association with oil and gas production and disposed of in a well, 216
if the well that is used either to facilitate production or for 217
disposal purposes is approved by the state and if the state 218
determines that the injection or disposal will not result in the 219
degradation of ground or surface water resources.220

       (Z) "Process generated waste water" means water that is 221
directly or indirectly used in the operation of an animal feeding 222
facility for any of the following: 223

       (1) Spillage or overflow from animal watering systems; 224

       (2) Washing, cleaning, or flushing pens, barns, manure pits, 225
or other areas of an animal feeding facility; 226

       (3) Direct contact swimming, washing, or spray cooling of 227
animals; 228

       (4) Dust control. 229

       (Z)(AA) "Process waste water" means any process generated 230
waste water and any precipitation, including rain or snow, that 231
comes into contact with manure, litter, bedding, or any other raw 232
material or intermediate or final material or product used in or 233
resulting from the production of animals or direct products such 234
as milk or eggs. 235

       (AA)(BB) "Production area" means any of the following 236
components of an animal feeding facility: 237

        (1) Animal confinement areas, including, but not limited to, 238
open lots, housed lots, feedlots, confinement houses, stall barns, 239
free stall barns, milkrooms, milking centers, cowyards, barnyards, 240
medication pens, animal walkways, and stables; 241

        (2) Manure storage areas, including, but not limited to, 242
manure storage or treatment facilities; 243

        (3) Raw material storage areas, including, but not limited 244
to, feed silos, silage bunkers, commodity buildings, and bedding 245
materials; 246

        (4) Waste containment areas, including, but not limited to, 247
any of the following: 248

       (a) An egg washing or egg processing facility; 249

       (b) An area used in the storage, handling, treatment, or 250
disposal of mortalities; 251

       (c) Settling basins, runoff ponds, liquid impoundments, and 252
areas within berms and diversions that are designed and maintained 253
to separate uncontaminated storm water runoff from contaminated 254
water and to contain and treat contaminated storm water runoff. 255

       (BB)(CC) "Public meeting" means a nonadversarial public 256
hearing at which a person may present written or oral statements 257
for the director of agriculture's consideration and includes 258
public hearings held under section 6111.12 of the Revised Code. 259

       (CC)(DD) "Review compliance certificate" means a certificate 260
issued under section 903.04 of the Revised Code. 261

       (DD)(EE) "Rule" means a rule adopted under section 903.10 of 262
the Revised Code. 263

       (EE)(FF) "Small concentrated animal feeding operation" means 264
an animal feeding facility that is not a large or medium 265
concentrated animal feeding operation and that is designated by 266
the director as a small concentrated animal feeding operation 267
pursuant to rules. 268

        (FF)(GG) "Waters of the state" has the same meaning as in 269
section 6111.01 of the Revised Code. 270

       Sec. 903.02.  (A)(1) Not later than one hundred eighty days 271
after March 15, 2001, the director of agriculture shall prepare a 272
program for the issuance of permits to install under this section. 273

       (2) On and after the date on which the director has finalized 274
the program required under division (A)(1) of this section, no 275
person shall modify an existing or construct a new concentrated 276
animal feeding facility without first obtaining a permit to 277
install issued by the director under this section. 278

       (B) The director or the director's authorized representative 279
may help an applicant for a permit to install during the 280
permitting process by providing guidance and technical assistance. 281

       (C) An applicant for a permit to install shall submit an 282
application to the director on a form that the director prescribes 283
and provides together with a fee in an amount established by rule. 284
The applicant shall include with the application all of the 285
following information: 286

       (1) The name and address of the applicant, of all partners if 287
the applicant is a partnership, of all members if the applicant is 288
a limited liability company, or of all officers and directors if 289
the applicant is a corporation, and of any other person who has a 290
right to control or in fact controls management of the applicant 291
or the selection of officers, directors, or managers of the 292
applicant;. As used in division (C)(1) of this section, "control" 293
means the power, directly or indirectly, to direct the management 294
and policies of the applicant through the ownership of voting 295
securities, by contract, through a right of approval or 296
disapproval, or otherwise unless the power is held by a chartered 297
lending institution as a result of debt liability.298

       (2) The type of livestock and the number of animals that the 299
concentrated animal feeding facility would have the design 300
capacity to raise or maintain; 301

       (3) Designs and plans for the proposed construction of the 302
concentrated animal feeding facility that include the proposed 303
location of the construction, design and construction plans and 304
specifications, anticipated beginning and ending dates for work 305
performed, and any other information that the director requires by 306
rule; 307

       (4) In the case of an application for a concentrated animal 308
feeding facility that meets the criteria established in sections 309
307.204 and 505.266 of the Revised Code, written statements from 310
the board of county commissioners of the county and the board of 311
township trustees of the township in which the concentrated animal 312
feeding facility would be located certifying that, in accordance 313
with those sections, the applicant has provided the boards with 314
the required written notification and that final recommendations 315
were selected regarding improvements, if any, to county or 316
township infrastructure that are needed as a result of the new or 317
expanded concentrated animal feeding facility and the costs of 318
those improvements; 319

       (5) A statement of the quantity of water that the 320
concentrated animal feeding facility will utilize on an average 321
daily and annual basis, a detailed description of the basis for 322
the calculation utilized in determining the quantity of water 323
utilized, and a statement identifying the source for the water; 324

       (6) Information concerning the applicant's past compliance 325
with the Federal Water Pollution Control Actlaws pertaining to 326
environmental protection that is required to be provided under 327
section 903.05 of the Revised Code, if applicable; 328

       (7) Any other information required by rule. 329

       Information required to be included in an application for the 330
modification of a permit to install, together with the applicable 331
fee amount, shall be established in rules. 332

       (D) The director shall issue permits to install in accordance 333
with section 903.09 of the Revised Code. The director shall deny a 334
permit to install if either of the following applies: 335

       (1) The permit application contains misleading or false 336
information. 337

       (2) The designs and plans fail to conform to best management 338
practices. 339

       Additional grounds for the denial of a permit to install 340
shall be those established in this chapter and rules. 341

       (E) A permit to install shall expire after a period specified 342
by the director unless the applicant has undertaken a continuing 343
program of construction or has entered into a binding contractual 344
obligation to undertake and complete a continuing program of 345
construction within a reasonable time. The director may extend the 346
expiration date of a permit to install upon request of the 347
applicant. 348

       (F) The director may modify, suspend, or revoke a permit to 349
install in accordance with rules. 350

       (G) Nothing in this chapter affects section 1521.16 of the 351
Revised Code. 352

       (H) The owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding 353
facility who proposes to make a major operational change at the 354
facility shall submit an application for approval of the change to 355
the director in accordance with rules.356

       Sec. 903.03.  (A)(1) Not later than one hundred eighty days 357
after the effective date of this sectionMarch 15, 2001, the 358
director of agriculture shall prepare a program for the issuance 359
of permits to operate under this section. 360

       (2) Except for a concentrated animal feeding facility that is 361
operating under an installation permit or a review compliance 362
certificate, on and after the date on which the director has 363
finalized the program required under division (A)(1) of this 364
section, no person shall own or operate a concentrated animal 365
feeding facility without a permit to operate issued by the 366
director under this section. 367

       (B) The director or the director's authorized representative 368
may help an applicant for a permit to operate during the 369
permitting process by providing guidance and technical assistance. 370

       (C) An applicant for a permit to operate shall submit a fee 371
in an amount established by rule together with, except as 372
otherwise provided in division (E) of this section, an application 373
to the director on a form that the director prescribes and 374
provides. The applicant shall include with the application all of 375
the following information: 376

       (1) The name and address of the applicant, of all partners if 377
the applicant is a partnership, of all members if the applicant is 378
a limited liability company, or of all officers and directors if 379
the applicant is a corporation, and of any other person who has a 380
right to control or in fact controls management of the applicant 381
or the selection of officers, directors, or managers of the 382
applicant;. As used in division (C)(1) of this section, "control" 383
has the same meaning as in division (C)(1) of section 903.02 of 384
the Revised Code.385

       (2) Information concerning the applicant's past compliance 386
with the Federal Water Pollution Control Actlaws pertaining to 387
environmental protection that is required to be provided under 388
section 903.05 of the Revised Code, if applicable; 389

       (3) A manure management plan for the concentrated animal 390
feeding facility that conforms to best management practices 391
regarding the handling, storage, transportation, and land 392
application of manure generated at the facility and that contains 393
any other information required by rule; 394

       (4) An insect and rodent control plan for the concentrated 395
animal feeding facility that conforms to best management practices 396
and is prepared in accordance with section 903.06 of the Revised 397
Code; 398

       (5) In the case of an application for a major concentrated 399
animal feeding facility, written proof that the person who would 400
be responsible for the supervision of the management and handling 401
of manure at the facility has been issued a livestock manager 402
certification in accordance with section 903.07 of the Revised 403
Code or will obtain a livestock manager certification prior to 404
applying any manure to land. 405

       (D) The director shall issue permits to operate in accordance 406
with section 903.09 of the Revised Code. The director shall deny a 407
permit to operate if either of the following applies: 408

       (1) The permit application contains misleading or false 409
information; 410

       (2) The manure management plan or insect and rodent control 411
plan fails to conform to best management practices. 412

       Additional grounds for the denial of a permit to operate 413
shall be those established in this chapter and in rules. 414

       (E) The director shall issue general permits to operate for 415
categories of concentrated animal feeding facilities that will 416
apply in lieu of individual permits to operate, provided that each 417
category of facilities meets all of the criteria established in 418
rules for general permits to operate. A person who is required to 419
obtain a permit to operate shall submit to the director a notice 420
of the person's intent to be covered under an existing general 421
permit or, at the person's option, shall submit an application for 422
an individual permit to operate. Upon receipt of a notice of 423
intent to be covered under an existing general permit, the 424
director shall notify the applicant in writing that the person is 425
covered by the general permit if the person satisfies the criteria 426
established in rules for eligibility for such coverage. If the 427
person is ineligible for coverage under the general permit, the 428
director shall require the submission of an application for an 429
individual permit to operate. 430

       (F) A permit to operate shall be valid for a period of five 431
years. 432

       (G) A permit to operate may be renewed. An application for 433
renewal of a permit to operate shall be submitted to the director 434
at least one hundred eighty days prior to the expiration date of 435
the permit to operate and shall comply with the requirements 436
governing applications for permits to operate that are established 437
under this section and by rules, including requirements pertaining 438
to public notice and participation. 439

       (H) The director may modify, suspend, or revoke a permit to 440
operate in accordance with rules. 441

       (I) The owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding 442
facility who proposes to make a major operational change at the 443
facility shall submit an application for approval of the change to 444
the director in accordance with rules.445

       Sec. 903.04.  (A) As used in this section, "existing 446
concentrated animal feeding facility" or "existing facility" means 447
a concentrated animal feeding facility that was in existence prior 448
to the date on which the director of agriculture has finalized the 449
program required under division (A)(1) of section 903.03 of the 450
Revised Code and that has received an installation permit prior to 451
that date. 452

       (B) On and after the date on which the director of 453
agriculture has finalized the program required under division 454
(A)(1) of section 903.02 of the Revised Code, the authority to 455
enforce terms and conditions of installation permits that 456
previously were issued to animal feeding facilities shall be 457
transferred from the director of environmental protection to the 458
director of agriculture. Thereafter, the director of environmental 459
protection shall have no authority to enforce the terms and 460
conditions of those installation permits. On and after the date on 461
which the director of agriculture has finalized the program 462
required under division (A)(1) of section 903.02 of the Revised 463
Code, an installation permit concerning which enforcement 464
authority has been transferred shall be deemed to have been issued 465
under this section. 466

       (C) A person to whom an installation permit has been issued 467
by the director of environmental protection prior to the date on 468
which the director of agriculture has finalized the program 469
required under division (A)(1) of section 903.03 of the Revised 470
Code may continue to operate under that permit until either of the 471
following occurs: 472

       (1) The installation permit is terminated through the denial 473
of a review compliance certificate under division (F) of this 474
section. 475

       (2) The person is required under division (H) of this section 476
to obtain a permit to operate. 477

       (D) Except as otherwise provided in this division, on and 478
after the date that is two years after the date on which the 479
director has finalized the program required under division (A)(1) 480
of section 903.03 of the Revised Code, and until the issuance of a 481
permit to operate, no person shall own or operate an existing 482
concentrated animal feeding facility unless the person holds a 483
review compliance certificate. 484

       This division does not apply to a person who has made a 485
timely submittal of the information required under division (E)(2) 486
of this section and who is waiting for the director to issue or 487
deny a review compliance certificate. Such a person may continue 488
the operation of the existing concentrated animal feeding facility 489
until, if applicable, the director issues an order denying the 490
review compliance certificate. 491

       (E) Not later than two years after the date on which the 492
director has finalized the program required under division (A)(1) 493
of section 903.03 of the Revised Code, both of the following 494
apply: 495

       (1) The director shall review the installation permit that 496
previously was issued to an existing concentrated animal feeding 497
facility and shall inspect the facility to determine if it is in 498
compliance with that permit. 499

       (2) Except as otherwise provided in division (E)(2) of this 500
section, the owner or operator of an existing concentrated animal 501
feeding facility shall furnish all of the following to the 502
director on a form prescribed by the director: 503

       (a) The name and address of the owner, of all partners if the 504
owner is a partnership, of all members if the owner is a limited 505
liability company, or of all officers and directors if the owner 506
is a corporation, and of any other person who has a right to 507
control or in fact controls management of the facility or the 508
selection of officers, directors, or managers of the facility;. As 509
used in division (E)(2)(a) of this section, "control" has the same 510
meaning as in division (C)(1) of section 903.02 of the Revised 511
Code.512

       (b) The type of livestock and number of animals that the 513
facility has the design capacity to raise or maintain; 514

       (c) A manure management plan for the facility that conforms 515
to best management practices regarding the handling, storage, 516
transportation, and land application of manure generated at the 517
facility and that contains any other information required by rule. 518
However, if a manure management plan submitted under division 519
(E)(2)(c) of this section does not conform with best management 520
practices regarding the handling, storage, transportation, and 521
land application of manure generated at the facility, the director 522
nevertheless shall deem the plan to conform with best management 523
practices if the owner or operator does all of the following: 524

        (i) Performs a phosphorous index risk assessment procedure or 525
a phosphorous soil test risk assessment procedure in accordance 526
with rules; 527

       (ii) Demonstrates that the facility cannot comply with best 528
management practices before the date on which the review 529
compliance certificate is to be issued; 530

       (iii) Includes in the manure management plan an 531
implementation plan under which the facility will comply with best 532
management practices on or before December 31, 2006. 533

       (d) An insect and rodent control plan for the facility that 534
conforms to best management practices and is prepared in 535
accordance with section 903.06 of the Revised Code; 536

       (e) In the case of a major concentrated animal feeding 537
facility, written proof that the person who would be responsible 538
for the supervision of the management and handling of manure at 539
the facility has been issued a livestock manager certification in 540
accordance with section 903.07 of the Revised Code. 541

       The owner or operator need not furnish any information 542
otherwise required under division (E)(2) of this section if that 543
information is included in the installation permit that was issued 544
for the existing facility. 545

       (F) After a review of the existing installation permit, an 546
inspection of the facility, and a review of the information 547
furnished under division (E)(2) of this section, and upon 548
determining that the existing facility is being operated in a 549
manner that protects the waters of the state and minimizes the 550
presence and negative effects of insects and rodents at the 551
facility and in surrounding areas, the director shall issue an 552
order issuing a review compliance certificate to the facility. In 553
issuing the certificate, the director shall consider technical 554
feasibility and economic costs. The director shall not require a 555
significant capital expenditure, as defined by rule, by the 556
facility before issuing a certificate. 557

       The director may issue an order denying a review compliance 558
certificate if the facility's insect and rodent control plan or 559
manure management plan does not conform to best management 560
practices and the requirements established in section 903.06 of 561
the Revised Code and in rules. The denial of a review compliance 562
certificate terminates the existing installation permit that was 563
issued to the facility. 564

       The issuance of a review compliance certificate shall not 565
require public notice or a public meeting. However, notice shall 566
be provided to persons who own property that is contiguous to the 567
production area of the concentrated animal feeding facility for 568
which the review compliance certificate is to be issued. Such 569
persons may submit written comments to the director within a time 570
established by the director. 571

       The issuance of a review compliance certificate shall not be 572
subject to appeal under Chapter 119. or sections 3745.04 to 573
3745.06 of the Revised Code. The denial or revocation of a review 574
compliance certificate or the amendment of an installation permit 575
resulting from a certificate may be challenged by the applicant in 576
an administrative hearing in accordance with Chapter 119. of the 577
Revised Code, except that section 119.12 of the Revised Code does 578
not apply. An order of the director that denies or revokes a 579
certificate or amends an installation permit as a result of a 580
certificate may be appealed to the environmental review appeals 581
commission under sections 3745.04 to 3745.06 of the Revised Code. 582

       (G) Upon the issuance of a review compliance certificate, the 583
certificate automatically shall merge and become a part of the 584
previously issued installation permit. If any of the terms and 585
conditions of the installation permit and the review compliance 586
certificate are in conflict, the terms and conditions of the 587
review compliance certificate are controlling. 588

       (H)(1) A review compliance certificate is valid for a period 589
of five years. Not later than one hundred eighty days prior to the 590
expiration date of the review compliance certificate, the owner or 591
operator shall apply for a permit to operate. 592

       (2) The director may revoke a review compliance certificate 593
issued to an existing facility after the director has issued an 594
order as a result of a hearing held under Chapter 119. of the 595
Revised Code in which the facility has been found to be in 596
violation of the terms and conditions of the review compliance 597
certificate. An existing facility whose review compliance 598
certificate is revoked shall obtain a permit to operate and, if 599
applicable, a NPDES permit in order to resume operating. 600

       (I) An existing facility that is issued a review compliance 601
certificate shall comply with the previously issued installation 602
permit, as amended by the certificate. 603

       Sec. 903.05.  (A) Each application for a permit to install or 604
permit to operate a concentrated animal feeding facility that is 605
submitted by an applicant who has not owned or operated a 606
concentrated animal feeding facility in this state for at least 607
two of the five years immediately preceding the submission of the 608
application shall be accompanied by all of the following: 609

       (1) A listing of all animal feeding facilities that the owner 610
or operator of the proposed new or modified concentrated animal 611
feeding facilityapplicant or any person identified by the 612
applicant under division (C)(1) of section 903.02 or 903.03 of the 613
Revised Code owns, has owned, has operated, or is operating in 614
this state; 615

       (2) A listing of the animal feeding facilities that the owner 616
or operatorapplicant or any person identified by the applicant 617
under division (C)(1) of section 903.02 or 903.03 of the Revised 618
Code owns, has owned, has operated, or is operating elsewhere in 619
the United States and that are regulated under the Federal Water 620
Pollution Control Act together with a listing of the animal 621
feeding facilities that the owner or operatorapplicant or any 622
such person owns, has owned, has operated, or is operating outside 623
the United States; 624

       (3) A listing of all administrative enforcement orders issued 625
to the owner or operatorapplicant or any person identified by the 626
applicant under division (C)(1) of section 903.02 or 903.03 of the 627
Revised Code, all civil actions in which the owner or operator628
applicant or any such person was determined by the trier of fact 629
to be liable in damages or was the subject of injunctive relief or 630
another type of civil relief, and all criminal actions in which 631
the owner or operatorapplicant or any such person pleaded guilty 632
or was convicted, during the five years immediately preceding the 633
submission of the application, in connection with any violation of 634
the federalFederal Water Pollution Control Act, the "Safe 635
Drinking Water Act," as defined in section 6109.01 of the Revised 636
Code, or any other applicable state laws pertaining to 637
environmental protection that was alleged to have occurred or to 638
be occurring at any animal feeding facility that the owner or 639
operatorapplicant or any such person owns, has owned, has 640
operated, or is operating in the United States or with any 641
violation of the environmental laws of another country that was 642
alleged to have occurred or to be occurring at any animal feeding 643
facility that the owner or operatorapplicant or any such person 644
owns, has owned, has operated, or is operating outside the United 645
States. 646

       The lists of animal feeding facilities owned or operated by 647
the owner or operatorapplicant or any person identified by the 648
applicant under division (C)(1) of section 903.02 or 903.03 of the 649
Revised Code within or outside this state or outside the United 650
States shall include, respectively, all such facilities owned or651
operated by the owner or operatorapplicant or any such person652
during the five-year period immediately preceding the submission 653
of the application. 654

       (B) If the applicant for a permit to install or permit to 655
operate or any person identified by the applicant under division 656
(C)(1) of section 903.02 or 903.03 of the Revised Code has been 657
involved in any prior activity involving the operation of an 658
animal feeding facility, the director of agriculture may deny the 659
application if the director finds from the application, the 660
information submitted under divisions (A)(1) to (3) of this 661
section, pertinent information submitted to the director, and 662
other pertinent information obtained by the director at the 663
director's discretion that the applicant and persons associated 664
with the applicantany such person, in the operation of animal 665
feeding facilities, have a history of substantial noncompliance 666
with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, the "Safe Drinking 667
Water Act," as defined in section 6109.01 of the Revised Code, any 668
other applicable state laws pertaining to environmental 669
protection, or the environmental laws of another country that 670
indicates that the applicant or any such person lacks sufficient 671
reliability, expertise, and competence to operate the proposed new 672
or modified concentrated animal feeding facility in substantial 673
compliance with this chapter and rules adopted under it. 674

       (C) A person who seeks to acquire or operate a concentrated 675
animal feeding facility that has been issued an installation 676
permit that has been transferred from the director of 677
environmental protection to the director of agriculture, a permit 678
to install, or a permit to operate shall submit to the director 679
the information specified in divisions (A)(1) to (3) of this 680
section prior to the transfer of the permit. The permit shall not 681
be transferred as otherwise provided in division (I) of section 682
903.09 of the Revised Code if the director finds from the 683
information submitted under divisions (A)(1) to (3) of this 684
section, pertinent information submitted to the director, and 685
other pertinent information obtained by the director at the 686
director's discretion that the person, in the operation of animal 687
feeding facilities, has a history of substantial noncompliance 688
with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, the "Safe Drinking 689
Water Act," as defined in section 6109.01 of the Revised Code, any 690
other applicable state laws pertaining to environmental 691
protection, or the environmental laws of another country that 692
indicates that the person lacks sufficient reliability, expertise, 693
and competence to operate the concentrated animal feeding facility 694
in substantial compliance with this chapter and rules adopted 695
under it. 696

       (D) An owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding 697
facility that has been issued an installation permit that has been 698
transferred from the director of environmental protection to the 699
director of agriculture, a permit to install, or a permit to 700
operate shall submit to the director notice of any proposed change 701
in the persons identified to the director under division (C)(1) of 702
section 903.02 or 903.03 of the Revised Code, as applicable. The 703
director may deny approval of the proposed change if the director 704
finds from the information submitted under divisions (A)(1) to (3) 705
of this section, pertinent information submitted to the director, 706
and other pertinent information obtained by the director at the 707
director's discretion that the proposed person, in the operation 708
of animal feeding facilities, has a history of substantial 709
noncompliance with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, the 710
"Safe Drinking Water Act," as defined in section 6109.01 of the 711
Revised Code, any other applicable state laws pertaining to 712
environmental protection, or the environmental laws of another 713
country that indicates that the person lacks sufficient 714
reliability, expertise, and competence to operate the concentrated 715
animal feeding facility in substantial compliance with this 716
chapter and rules adopted under it.717

       Sec. 903.06.  (A) As used in this section, "plan" means an 718
insect and rodent control plan prepared under this section. 719

       (B) An owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding 720
facility shall prepare and submit to the director of agriculture 721
in accordance with rules an insect and rodent control plan 722
designed to minimize the presence and negative effects of insects 723
and rodents at the concentrated animal feeding facility and in 724
surrounding areas, including land on which manure is stored or 725
applied. The plan shall conform to best management practices 726
established in rules. The director shall approve or deny the plan 727
within the time period established in rules by the director and 728
may require modification of the plan at that time or a later time 729
in accordance with rules. 730

       (C) On and after the date that is established in rules by the 731
director, no person shall own or operate a concentrated animal 732
feeding facility unless an insect and rodent control plan for the 733
facility has been approved by the director. The owner or operator 734
of a concentrated animal feeding facility shall not violate the 735
facility's insect and rodent control plan. 736

       (D) The director shall enforce an insect and rodent control 737
plan in accordance with rules and shall assess a civil penalty in 738
accordance with rules and section 903.16 of the Revised Code 739
against an owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding 740
facility who owns or operates it without a plan approved by the 741
director or who violates the facility's plan. 742

       Sec. 903.07.  (A) On and after the date that is established 743
in rules by the director of agriculture, both of the following 744
apply: 745

       (1) The management and handling of manure at a major 746
concentrated animal feeding facility, including the land 747
application of manure or the removal of manure from a manure 748
storage or treatment facility, shall be conducted only by or under 749
the supervision of a person holding a livestock manager 750
certification issued under this section. A person managing or 751
handling manure who is acting under the instructions and control 752
of a person holding a livestock manager certification is 753
considered to be under the supervision of the certificate holder 754
if the certificate holder is responsible for the actions of the 755
person and is available when needed even though the certificate 756
holder is not physically present at the time of the manure 757
management or handling. 758

       (2) No person shall transport and land apply annually or buy, 759
sell, or land apply annually the volume of manure established in 760
rules adopted by the director under division (E)(5) of section 761
903.10 of the Revised Code unless the person holds a livestock 762
manager certification issued under this section. 763

       (B) The director shall issue a livestock manager 764
certification to a person who has submitted a complete application 765
for certification on a form prescribed and provided by the 766
director, together with the appropriate application fee, and who 767
has completed successfully the required training and has passed 768
the required examination. The director may suspend or revoke a 769
livestock manager certification and may reinstate a suspended or 770
revoked livestock manager certification in accordance with rules. 771

       (C) Information required to be included in an application for 772
a livestock manager certification, the amount of the application 773
fee, and requirements regarding training and the examination, 774
requirements governing the management and handling of manure, 775
including the land application of manure, and requirements 776
governing the keeping of records regarding the handling of manure, 777
including the land application of manure, shall be established in 778
rules. 779

       Sec. 903.08.  (A)(1) The director of agriculture is 780
authorized to participate in the national pollutant discharge 781
elimination system in accordance with the Federal Water Pollution 782
Control Act. Not later than one hundred eighty days after March 783
15, 2001, the director shall prepare a state program in accordance 784
with 40 C.F.R. 123.21 for point sources that are subject to this 785
section and shall submit the program to the United States 786
environmental protection agency for approval. 787

       (2) On and after the date on which the United States 788
environmental protection agency approves the state program 789
submitted under division (A)(1) of this section, the authority to 790
enforce terms and conditions of NPDES permits previously issued 791
under division (J) of section 6111.03 or under section 6111.035 of 792
the Revised Code for the discharging, transporting, or handling of 793
storm water from an animal feeding facility or of manure794
pollutants from concentrated animal feeding operations is 795
transferred from the director of environmental protection to the 796
director of agriculture. Thereafter, the director of 797
environmental protection shall have no authority to enforce the 798
terms and conditions of those NPDES permits. After the transfer 799
of authority under division (A)(2) of this section, the NPDES 800
permits concerning which authority has been transferred shall be 801
considered to have been issued under this section. 802

       (B)(1) On and after the date on which the United States 803
environmental protection agency approves the NPDES program 804
submitted by the director of agriculture under this section, no 805
person shall discharge manurepollutants from a point source806
concentrated animal feeding operation into waters of the state 807
without first obtaining a NPDES permit issued by the director of 808
agriculture under this section. Any person that is required by the 809
Federal Water Pollution Control Act to obtain a permit for the 810
discharge of manurepollutants from a concentrated animal feeding 811
operation shall apply to the director for an individual NPDES 812
permit or for coverage under a general NPDES permit. The director 813
is authorized to issue, revoke, modify, or deny such an individual 814
permit or issue, revoke, or deny coverage under a general permit 815
in compliance with all requirements of the Federal Water Pollution 816
Control Act. Violation of division (B)(1) of this section is 817
hereby declared to be a public nuisance for purposes of state 818
enforcement of this section. 819

       (2) Persons that have been issued a permit by the director of 820
environmental protection under division (J) of section 6111.03 of 821
the Revised Code for the discharge of manurepollutants from a 822
concentrated animal feeding operation into the waters of the state823
prior to the date on which the United States environmental 824
protection agency approves the NPDES program submitted by the 825
director of agriculture under this section may continue to operate 826
under that permit until it expires or is modified or revoked. Such 827
a permit shall be enforced by the director of agriculture upon the 828
transfer of authority to enforce the terms and conditions of the 829
permit under division (A)(2) of this section. 830

       (C)(1) On and after the date on which the United States 831
environmental protection agency approves the NPDES program 832
submitted by the director of agriculture under this section, no 833
person shall discharge storm water resulting from an animal 834
feeding facility without first obtaining a NPDES permit issued by 835
the director of agriculture in accordance with rules when such a 836
permit is required by the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. 837
Violation of division (C)(1) of this section is hereby declared to 838
be a public nuisance for purposes of state enforcement of this 839
section. 840

       (2) Persons that have been issued a NPDES permit by the 841
director of environmental protection under Chapter 6111. of the 842
Revised Code for the discharge of storm water from an animal 843
feeding facility prior to the date on which the United States 844
environmental protection agency approves the NPDES program 845
submitted by the director of agriculture under this section may 846
continue to operate under that permit until it expires or is 847
modified or revoked. Such a permit shall be enforced by the 848
director of agriculture upon the transfer of authority to enforce 849
the terms and conditions of the permit under division (A)(2) of 850
this section. 851

       (D) In accordance with rules, an applicant for a NPDES permit 852
issued under this section shall submit a fee in an amount 853
established by rule together with, except as otherwise provided in 854
division (F) of this section, an application for the permit to the 855
director of agriculture on a form prescribed by the director. The 856
application shall include any information required by rule. The 857
director or the director's authorized representative may help an 858
applicant for a NPDES permit during the application process by 859
providing guidance and technical assistance. 860

       (E) The director of agriculture shall issue NPDES permits in 861
accordance with this section and section 903.09 of the Revised 862
Code. The director shall deny an application for a NPDES permit if 863
any of the following applies: 864

       (1) The application contains misleading or false information. 865

       (2) The administrator of the United States environmental 866
protection agency objects in writing to the issuance of the NPDES 867
permit in accordance with section 402(d) of the Federal Water 868
Pollution Control Act. 869

       (3) The director determines that the proposed discharge or 870
source would conflict with an areawide waste treatment management 871
plan adopted in accordance with section 208 of the Federal Water 872
Pollution Control Act. 873

       Additional grounds for the denial of a NPDES permit shall be 874
those established in this chapter and rules. 875

       (F) To the extent consistent with the Federal Water Pollution 876
Control Act, the director of agriculture shall issue general NPDES 877
permits that will apply in lieu of individual NPDES permits for 878
categories of point sources for which the director determines that 879
all of the following apply: 880

       (1) Any discharges authorized by a general permit will have 881
only minimal cumulative adverse effects on the environment when 882
the discharges are considered collectively and individually. 883

       (2) The discharges are more appropriately authorized by a 884
general permit than by an individual permit. 885

       (3) Each category of point sources satisfies the criteria 886
established in rules. 887

       A person who is required to obtain a NPDES permit shall 888
submit to the director a notice of the person's intent to be 889
covered under an existing general permit or, at the person's 890
option, an application for an individual NPDES permit. Upon 891
receipt of a notice of intent for coverage under an existing 892
general permit, the director shall notify the applicant in writing 893
that the person is covered by the general permit if the person 894
satisfies the criteria established in rules for eligibility for 895
such coverage. If the person is ineligible for coverage under the 896
general permit, the director shall require the submission of an 897
application for an individual NPDES permit. 898

       (G) The director of agriculture shall establish terms and 899
conditions of NPDES permits in accordance with rules. Terms and 900
conditions shall be designed to achieve and maintain full 901
compliance with national effluent limitations, national standards 902
of performance for new sources, the most current water quality 903
standards adopted under section 6111.041 of the Revised Code, the 904
most current antidegradation policy adopted under section 6111.12 905
of the Revised Code, and other requirements of the Federal Water 906
Pollution Control Act. In establishing the terms and conditions of 907
a NPDES permit, the director, to the extent consistent with that 908
act, shall consider technical feasibility and economic costs and 909
shall allow a reasonable period of time for coming into compliance 910
with the permit. 911

       (H) An animal feeding facility that is required to obtain 912
both a NPDES permit and a permit to operate shall be issued a 913
single permit to operate incorporating the terms and conditions 914
established by both permits. The permit to operate expressly shall 915
designate the terms and conditions required under the NPDES 916
program as federally enforceable. All other provisions are 917
enforceable under state law only and expressly shall be designated 918
accordingly. 919

       (I) A NPDES permit may be issued under this section for a 920
period not to exceed five years. 921

       (J) A NPDES permit issued under this section may be renewed. 922
An application for renewal of a NPDES permit shall be submitted to 923
the director of agriculture at least one hundred eighty days prior 924
to the expiration date of the permit and shall comply with the 925
requirements governing applications for NPDES permits established 926
under this section and by rule. 927

       (K)(1) No person shall make any false statement, 928
representation, or certification in an application for a NPDES 929
permit or in any form, notice, or report required to be submitted 930
to the director pursuant to terms and conditions established in a 931
NPDES permit issued under this section. 932

       (2) No person shall render inaccurate any monitoring method 933
or device that is required under the terms and conditions of a 934
NPDES permit issued under this section. 935

       (L) The director may modify, suspend, or revoke a NPDES 936
permit issued under this section for cause as established by rule. 937
No NPDES permit issued under this section shall be modified, 938
suspended, or revoked without a written order stating the findings 939
that led to the modification, suspension, or revocation. In 940
addition, the permittee has a right to an administrative hearing 941
in accordance with Chapter 119. of the Revised Code, except that 942
section 119.12 of the Revised Code does not apply. Further, an 943
order of the director modifying, suspending, or revoking a NPDES 944
permit may be appealed to the environmental review appeals 945
commission under sections 3745.04 to 3745.06 of the Revised Code. 946

       (M)(1) No person shall violate any effluent limitation 947
established by rule. 948

       (2) No person shall violate any other provision of a NPDES 949
permit issued under this section. 950

       (3) Compliance with a NPDES permit issued under this section 951
constitutes compliance with this section. 952

       (N) This section, including the state program authorized in 953
division (A)(1) of this section, shall be administered in a manner 954
consistent with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. 955

       Sec. 903.081. (A) For purposes of section 903.08 of the 956
Revised Code, no person shall issueapprove all or portions of a 957
NPDES permit if the person receives or has received during the two 958
years prior to the receipt of an application for a NPDES permit a 959
significant portion of income from any NPDES permittee or any 960
applicant for a NPDES permit. In addition, no person who,may 961
serve on a board or commission that approves all or portions of a 962
NPDES permit, including taking such action pursuant to an appeal 963
of an action regarding a NPDES permit, has the authority to 964
require or to order the director of agriculture to vacate or 965
modify a NPDES permit shall require or order the director to 966
vacate or modify a NPDES permit if the person receives or has 967
received during the two years prior to serving on the board or 968
commission or to the filing of the appeal a significant portion 969
of income from any NPDES permittee or any applicant for a NPDES 970
permit. 971

        (B) As used in this section: 972

        (1) "Significant portion of income" means ten per cent or 973
more of gross personal income in a calendar year or fifty per cent 974
or more of gross personal income in a calendar year if the 975
recipient of the income is more than sixty years of age and is 976
receiving that portion of income under retirement benefits, 977
including a pension or similar arrangement. 978

        (2) "Income" includes retirement benefits, consultant fees, 979
and stock dividends. "Income" does not include mutual fund 980
payments or other diversified investments for which the recipient 981
does not know the identity of the primary sources of the income. 982

        (3) "Permittee" and "applicant for a NPDES permit" does not 983
include any department or agency of the state. 984

       Sec. 903.082. (A) The director of agriculture may determine 985
that an animal feeding facility that is not a medium concentrated 986
animal feeding operation or small concentrated animal feeding 987
operation as defined in section 903.01 of the Revised Code988
facility nevertheless shall be required to be permitted as a 989
medium or small concentrated animal feeding operationapply for 990
and receive a permit to operate when all of the following apply:991

        (1) The director has received from the chief of the division 992
of soil and water resources in the department of natural resources 993
a copy of an order issued under section 1511.02 of the Revised 994
Code that specifies that the animal feeding facility has caused 995
agricultural pollution by failure to comply with standards 996
established under that section and that the animal feeding 997
facility therefore should be required to be permitted as a medium 998
or small concentrated animal feeding operationfacility.999

        (2) The director or the director's authorized representative 1000
has inspected the animal feeding facility.1001

        (3) The director or the director's authorized representative 1002
finds that the facility is not being operated in a manner that 1003
protects the waters of the state.1004

        (B) If an animal feeding facility is required to be permitted 1005
in accordance with this section, the owner or operator of the 1006
facility shall apply to the director for a permit to operate as a 1007
concentrated animal feeding operation. In a situation in which 1008
best management practices cannot be implemented without modifying 1009
the existing animal feeding facility, the owner or operator of the 1010
facility also shall apply for a permit to install for the 1011
facility.1012

        (C) In the case of an animal feeding facility for which a 1013
permit to operate is required under this section, a permit to 1014
operate shall not be required after the end of the five-year term 1015
of the permit if the problems that caused the facility to be 1016
required to obtain the permit have been corrected to the 1017
director's satisfaction.1018

       Sec. 903.09. (A) Prior to issuing or modifying a permit to 1019
install, permit to operate, or NPDES permit, the director of 1020
agriculture shall issue a draft permit. The director or the 1021
director's representative shall mail notice of the issuance of a 1022
draft permit to the applicant and shall publish the notice once in 1023
a newspaper of general circulation in the county in which the 1024
concentrated animal feeding facility or discharger is located or 1025
proposed to be located. The director shall mail notice of the 1026
issuance of a draft permit and a copy of the draft permit to the 1027
board of county commissioners of the county and the board of 1028
township trustees of the township in which the concentrated animal 1029
feeding facility or discharger is located or proposed to be 1030
located. The director or the director's representative also shall 1031
provide notice of the issuance of a draft NPDES permit to any 1032
other persons that are entitled to notice under the Federal Water 1033
Pollution Control Act. Notice of the issuance of a draft permit 1034
to install, permit to operate, or NPDES permit shall include the 1035
address where written comments concerning the draft permit may be 1036
submitted and the period of time during which comments will be 1037
accepted as established by rule. 1038

       If the director receives written comments in an amount that 1039
demonstrates significant public interest, as defined by rule, in 1040
the draft permit, the director shall schedule one public meeting 1041
to provide information to the public and to hear comments 1042
pertinent to the draft permit. The notice of the public meeting 1043
shall be provided in the same manner as the notice of the issuance 1044
of the draft permit. 1045

       (B) If a person is required to obtain both a permit to 1046
install and a permit to operate, including any permit to operate 1047
with NPDES provisions, and public meetings are required for both 1048
permits, the public meetings for the permits shall be combined. 1049

       (C) The director shall apply the antidegradation policy 1050
adopted under section 6111.12 of the Revised Code to permits 1051
issued under this chapter to the same degree and under the same 1052
circumstances as it applies to permits issued under Chapter 6111. 1053
of the Revised Code. The director shall hold one public meeting 1054
to consider antidegradation issues when such a meeting is required 1055
by the antidegradation policy. When allowed by the antidegradation 1056
policy, the director shall hold the public meeting on 1057
antidegradation issues concurrently with any public meeting held 1058
for the draft permit. 1059

       (D) The director or the director's representative shall 1060
publish notice of the issuance of a final permit to install, 1061
permit to operate, or NPDES permit once in a newspaper of general 1062
circulation in the county in which the concentrated animal feeding 1063
facility or discharger is located. 1064

       (E) Failure of the director to provide notice or a public 1065
meeting shall invalidate a permit only if the failure is raised 1066
by, and was relied upon to the detriment of, a person that is 1067
entitled to appeal the permit. Notice or a public meeting is not 1068
required for the modification of a permit made with the consent of 1069
the permittee for the correction of typographical errors. 1070

       (F) The denial, modification, suspension, or revocation of a 1071
permit to install, permit to operate, or NPDES permit without the 1072
consent of the applicant or permittee shall be preceded by a 1073
proposed action stating the director's intention to issue an order 1074
with respect to the permit and the reasons for it. 1075

       The director shall mail to the applicant or the permittee 1076
notice of the director's proposed action to deny, modify, suspend, 1077
or revoke a permit to install, permit to operate, or NPDES permit. 1078
The director shall publish the notice once in a newspaper of 1079
general circulation in the county in which the concentrated animal 1080
feeding facility or concentrated animal feeding operation is 1081
located or proposed to be located. The director shall mail a copy 1082
of the notice of the proposed action to the board of county 1083
commissioners of the county and to the board of township trustees 1084
of the township in which the concentrated animal feeding facility 1085
or concentrated animal feeding operation is located or proposed to 1086
be located. The director also shall provide notice of the 1087
director's proposed action to deny, modify, suspend, or revoke a 1088
permit to install, permit to operate, or NPDES permit to any other 1089
person that is entitled to notice under the Federal Water 1090
Pollution Control Act. The notice of the director's proposed 1091
action to deny, modify, suspend, or revoke a permit to install, 1092
permit to operate, or NPDES permit shall include the address where 1093
written comments concerning the director's proposed action may be 1094
submitted and the period of time during which comments will be 1095
accepted as established by rule. If the director receives written 1096
comments in an amount that demonstrates significant public 1097
interest, as defined by rule, the director shall schedule one 1098
public meeting to provide information to the public and to hear 1099
comments pertinent to the proposed action. The notice of the 1100
public meeting shall be provided in the same manner as the notice 1101
of the director's proposed action. 1102

        The director shall not issue an order that makes the proposed 1103
action final until the applicant or permittee has had an 1104
opportunity for an adjudication hearing in accordance with Chapter 1105
119. of the Revised Code, except that section 119.12 of the 1106
Revised Code does not apply. An order of the director that 1107
finalizes the proposed action or an order issuing a permit without 1108
a prior proposed action may be appealed to the environmental 1109
review appeals commission under sections 3745.04 to 3745.06 of the 1110
Revised Code. 1111

       (G)(1) The director shall issue an order issuing or denying 1112
an application for a permit to operate that contains NPDES 1113
provisions or for a NPDES permit, as well as any application for a 1114
permit to install that is submitted simultaneously, not later than 1115
one hundred eighty days after receiving the application. 1116

       (2) In the case of an application for a permit to install or 1117
permit to operate that is not connected with an application for a 1118
NPDES permit, the director shall issue or propose to deny the 1119
permit not later than ninety days after receiving the application. 1120
If the director has proposed to deny the permit to install or 1121
permit to operate under division (G)(2) of this section, the 1122
director shall issue an order denying the permit or, if the 1123
director decides against the proposed denial, issuing the permit 1124
not later than one hundred eighty days after receiving the 1125
application. If the director denies the permit, the director shall 1126
notify the applicant in writing of the reason for the denial. 1127

       (H) All rulemaking and the issuance of civil penalties under 1128
this chapter shall comply with Chapter 119. of the Revised Code. 1129

       (I) Upon the transfer of ownership of an animal feeding 1130
facility for which a permit to install, an installation permit, a 1131
review compliance certificate, or a permit to operate that 1132
contains no NPDES provisions has been issued, the permit or 1133
certificate shall be transferred to the new owner of the animal 1134
feeding facility except as provided in division (C) of section 1135
903.05 of the Revised Code. In the case of the transfer of 1136
ownership of a point source for which a NPDES permit or a permit 1137
to operate that contains NPDES provisions has been issued, the 1138
permit shall be transferred in accordance with rules. 1139

       (J) Applications for installation permits for animal feeding 1140
facilities pending before the director of environmental protection 1141
on the date on which the director of agriculture has finalized the 1142
programs required under division (A)(1) of section 903.02 and 1143
division (A)(1) of section 903.03 of the Revised Code shall be 1144
transferred to the director of agriculture. In the case of an 1145
applicant who is required to obtain a permit to install and a 1146
permit to operate under sections 903.02 and 903.03, respectively, 1147
of the Revised Code, the director of agriculture shall process the 1148
pending application for an installation permit as an application 1149
for a permit to install and a permit to operate. 1150

       (K) Applications for NPDES permits for either of the 1151
following that are pending before the director of environmental 1152
protection on the date on which the United States environmental 1153
protection agency approves the NPDES program submitted by the 1154
director of agriculture under section 903.08 of the Revised Code 1155
shall be transferred to the director of agriculture: 1156

       (1) The discharge of manurepollutants from a concentrated 1157
animal feeding operation; 1158

       (2) The discharge of storm water resulting from an animal 1159
feeding facility. In1160

       In the case of an applicant who is required to obtain a NPDES 1161
permit under section 903.08 of the Revised Code, the director of 1162
agriculture shall process the pending application as an 1163
application for a NPDES permit under that section. 1164

       Sec. 903.10.  The director of agriculture shallmay adopt 1165
rules in accordance with Chapter 119. of the Revised Code that do 1166
all of the following: 1167

       (A) Establish all of the following concerning permits to 1168
install and permits to operate: 1169

       (1) A description of what constitutes a modification of a 1170
concentrated animal feeding facility; 1171

       (2) A description of what constitutes a major operational 1172
change at a concentrated animal feeding facility;1173

       (3) The amount of the fee that must be submitted with each 1174
permit application and each application for a permit modification; 1175

       (3)(4) Information that must be included in the designs and 1176
plans required to be submitted with an application for a permit to 1177
install and criteria for approving, disapproving, or requiring 1178
modification of the designs and plans; 1179

       (4)(5) Information that must be included in a manure 1180
management plan required to be submitted with an application for a 1181
permit to operate; 1182

       (5)(6) Information that must be included in an application 1183
for the modification of an installation permit, a permit to 1184
install, or a permit to operate; 1185

       (6)(7) Information that must be included in an application 1186
for approval of a major operational change at a concentrated 1187
animal feeding facility;1188

       (8) Any additional information that must be included with a 1189
permit application; 1190

       (7)(9) Procedures for the issuance, denial, modification, 1191
transfer, suspension, and revocation of permits to install and 1192
permits to operate, including general permits; 1193

       (8)(10) Procedures for the approval or denial of an 1194
application for approval of a major operational change at a 1195
concentrated animal feeding facility;1196

       (11) Grounds for the denial, modification, suspension, or 1197
revocation of permits to install and permits to operate in 1198
addition to the grounds established in division (D) of section 1199
903.02 and division (D) of section 903.03 of the Revised Code; 1200

       (9)(12) Grounds for the denial of an application for approval 1201
of a major operational change at a concentrated animal feeding 1202
facility;1203

       (13) A requirement that a person that is required to obtain 1204
both a permit to install and a permit to operate submit 1205
applications for those permits simultaneously; 1206

       (10)(14) A definition of "general permit to operate" that 1207
establishes categories of concentrated animal feeding facilities 1208
to be covered under such a permit and a definition of "individual 1209
permit to operate" together with the criteria for issuing a 1210
general permit to operate and the criteria for determining a 1211
person's eligibility to operate under a general permit to operate. 1212

       (B) Establish all of the following for the purposes of review 1213
compliance certificates issued under section 903.04 of the Revised 1214
Code: 1215

       (1) The form of a certificate; 1216

       (2) Criteria for what constitutes a significant capital 1217
expenditure under division (D) of that section; 1218

       (3) Deadlines and procedures for submitting information under 1219
division (E)(2) of that section. 1220

       (C) Establish best management practices that minimize water 1221
pollution, odors, insects, and rodents, that govern the land 1222
application of manure that originated at a concentrated animal 1223
feeding facility, and that govern all of the following activities 1224
that occur at a concentrated animal feeding facility: 1225

       (1) Manure management, including the storage, handling, 1226
transportation, and land application of manure. Rules adopted 1227
under division (C)(1) of this section shall include practices that 1228
prevent surface and ground water contamination caused by the 1229
storage of manure or the land application of manure and prevent 1230
the contamination of water in drainage tiles that may be caused by 1231
that application. 1232

       (2) Disposal of dead livestock; 1233

       (3) Any other activity that the director considers 1234
appropriate. 1235

       Best management practices established in rules adopted under 1236
division (C) of this section shall not conflict with best 1237
management practices established in rules that have been adopted 1238
under any other section of the Revised Code and that are in effect 1239
on March 15, 2001. The rules adopted under division (C) of this 1240
section shall establish guidelines that require owners or 1241
operators of concentrated animal feeding facilities to consult 1242
with and work with local officials, including boards of county 1243
commissioners and boards of township trustees, in addressing 1244
issues related to local government infrastructure needs and the 1245
financing of that infrastructure. 1246

       (D) Establish all of the following concerning insect and 1247
rodent control plans required under section 903.06 of the Revised 1248
Code: 1249

       (1) The information to be included in an insect and rodent 1250
control plan; 1251

       (2) Criteria for approving, disapproving, or requiring 1252
modification of an insect and rodent control plan; 1253

       (3) Criteria for determining compliance with or violation of 1254
an insect and rodent control plan; 1255

       (4) Procedures and standards for monitoring insect and rodent 1256
control plans; 1257

       (5) Procedures and standards for enforcing insect and rodent 1258
control plans at concentrated animal feeding facilities at which 1259
insects or rodents constitute a nuisance or adversely affect 1260
public health; 1261

       (6) The amount of civil penalties for violation of an insect 1262
and rodent control plan assessed by the director of agriculture 1263
under division (B) of section 903.16 of the Revised Code, provided 1264
that the rules adopted under division (D)(6) of this section shall 1265
not establish a civil penalty of more than ten thousand dollars 1266
for a violation involving a concentrated animal feeding facility 1267
that is not a major concentrated animal feeding facility and shall 1268
not establish a civil penalty of more than twenty-five thousand 1269
dollars for a violation involving a major concentrated animal 1270
feeding facility; 1271

       (7) The time period within which the director must approve or 1272
deny an insect and rodent control plan after receiving it; 1273

       (8) Any other provisions necessary to administer and enforce 1274
section 903.12 of the Revised Code. 1275

       (E) Establish all of the following concerning livestock 1276
manager certificationcertifications required under section 903.07 1277
of the Revised Code: 1278

       (1) The information to be included in an application for a 1279
livestock manager certification and the amount of the application 1280
fee; 1281

       (2) The content of the training required to be completed and 1282
of the examination required to be passed by an applicant for a 1283
livestock manager certification. The training shall include and 1284
the examination shall test the applicant's knowledge of 1285
information on topics that include calculating nutrient values in 1286
manure, devising and implementing a plan for the land application 1287
of manure, removing manure held in a manure storage or treatment 1288
facility, and following best management practices established in 1289
rules for disposal of dead animals and manure management, 1290
including practices that control odor and protect the environment. 1291
The director may specify other types of recognized training 1292
programs that, if completed, are considered to satisfy the 1293
training and examination requirement. 1294

       (3) Criteria and procedures for the issuance, denial, 1295
suspension, revocation, or reinstatement of a livestock manager 1296
certification; 1297

       (4) The length of time during which livestock manager 1298
certifications will be valid and procedures for their renewal; 1299

       (5) The volume of manure that must be transported and land 1300
applied annually or the volume of manure that must be bought, 1301
sold, or land applied annually by a person in order for the person 1302
to be required to obtain a livestock manager certification under 1303
division (A)(2) of section 903.07 of the Revised Code; 1304

       (6) Requirements governing the management and handling of 1305
manure, including the land application of manure;1306

       (7) Requirements governing the keeping of records regarding 1307
the handling of manure, including the land application of manure;1308

       (8) Any other provisions necessary to administer and enforce 1309
section 903.07 of the Revised Code. 1310

       (F) Establish all of the following concerning NPDES permits: 1311

       (1) The designation of concentrated animal feeding operations 1312
that are subject to NPDES permit requirements under section 903.08 1313
of the Revised Code. This designation shall include only those 1314
point sources for which the issuance of NPDES permits is required 1315
under the Federal Water Pollution Control Act.;1316

       (2) Effluent limitations governing discharges into waters of 1317
the state that are authorized by permits; 1318

       (3) Variances from effluent limitations and other permit 1319
requirements to the extent that the variances are consistent with 1320
the Federal Water Pollution Control Act; 1321

       (4) Terms and conditions to be included in a permit, 1322
including, as applicable, best management practices; installation 1323
of discharge or water quality monitoring methods or equipment; 1324
creation and retention of records; submission of periodic reports; 1325
schedules of compliance; net volume, net weight, and, where 1326
necessary, concentration and mass loading limits of manure that 1327
may be discharged into waters of the state; and authorized 1328
duration and frequency of any discharges into waters of the state; 1329

       (5) Procedures for the submission of applications for permits 1330
and notices of intent to be covered by general permits, including 1331
information that must be included in the applications and notices; 1332

       (6) The amount of the fee that must be submitted with an 1333
application for a permit; 1334

       (7) Procedures for processing permit applications, including 1335
public notice and participation requirements; 1336

       (8) Procedures for notifying the United States environmental 1337
protection agency of the submission of permit applications, the 1338
director's action on those applications, and any other reasonable 1339
and relevant information; 1340

       (9) Procedures for notifying and receiving and responding to 1341
recommendations from other states whose waters may be affected by 1342
the issuance of a permit; 1343

       (10) Procedures for the transfer of permits to new owners or 1344
operators; 1345

       (11) Grounds and procedures for the issuance, denial, 1346
modification, suspension, or revocation of permits, including 1347
general permits; 1348

       (12) A definition of "general NPDES permit" that establishes 1349
categories of point sources to be covered under such a permit and 1350
a definition of "individual NPDES permit" together with the 1351
criteria for issuing a general NPDES permit and the criteria for 1352
determining a person's eligibility to discharge under a general 1353
NPDES permit. 1354

       The rules adopted under division (F) of this section shall be 1355
consistent with the requirements of the Federal Water Pollution 1356
Control Act. 1357

       (G) Establish public notice and participation requirements, 1358
in addition to the procedures established in rules adopted under 1359
division (F)(7) of this section, for the issuance, denial, 1360
modification, transfer, suspension, and revocation of permits to 1361
install, permits to operate, and NPDES permits consistent with 1362
section 903.09 of the Revised Code, including a definition of what 1363
constitutes significant public interest for the purposes of 1364
divisions (A) and (F) of section 903.09 of the Revised Code and 1365
procedures for public meetings. The rules shall require that 1366
information that is presented at such a public meeting be limited 1367
to the criteria that are applicable to the permit application that 1368
is the subject of the public meeting. 1369

       (H) Establish the amount of civil penalties assessed by the 1370
director of agriculture under division (B) of section 903.16 of 1371
the Revised Code for violation of the terms and conditions of a 1372
permit to install, permit to operate, or review compliance 1373
certificate, provided that the rules adopted under this division 1374
shall not establish a civil penalty of more than ten thousand 1375
dollars per day for each violation; 1376

       (I) Establish procedures for the protection of trade secrets 1377
from public disclosure. The procedures shall authorize the release 1378
of trade secrets to officers, employees, or authorized 1379
representatives of the state, another state, or the United States 1380
when necessary for an enforcement action brought under this 1381
chapter or when otherwise required by the Federal Water Pollution 1382
Control Act. The rules shall require at least ten days' written 1383
notice to the person to whom a trade secret applies prior to the 1384
release of the trade secret. Rules adopted under this division do 1385
not apply to any information that is contained in applications, 1386
including attachments, for NPDES permits and that is required to 1387
be submitted under section 903.08 of the Revised Code or rules 1388
adopted under division (F) of this section. 1389

       (J) Establish any other provisions necessary to administer 1390
and enforce this chapter. 1391

       Sec. 903.15.  (A) A person who is aggrieved or adversely 1392
affected by an alleged nuisance related to a concentrated animal 1393
feeding facility may submit a complaint to the director of 1394
agriculture alleging that the nuisance existsregarding a 1395
concentrated animal feeding facility or the discharge of a 1396
pollutant from an animal feeding operation. The complaint may be 1397
made orally or in writing. If the complaint is made in writing, it 1398
shall be signed by the person making it and dated. 1399

       (B) After receiving a written, signed, and dated complaint, 1400
the director shall, or after receiving an oral complaint the 1401
director may, cause an investigation to be conducted to determine 1402
if the owner or operator of the concentrated animal feeding 1403
facility is complying with athis chapter, rules adopted under 1404
it, or any terms and conditions of any permit or review 1405
compliance certificateissued under it or to determine if a 1406
discharge of a pollutant is occurring or has occurred at the 1407
animal feeding operation. 1408

       (C)(1) If, upon completion of the investigation, the director 1409
determines that the owner or operator is in compliance with a1410
this chapter, rules adopted under it, or any terms and conditions 1411
of any permit or review compliance certificateissued under it or 1412
determines that a discharge of a pollutant is not occurring or has 1413
not occurred at the animal feeding operation, the director shall 1414
dismiss the complaint and notify the complainant and the owner or 1415
operator of the concentrated animal feeding facility or animal 1416
feeding operation, whichever is applicable, of the dismissal. 1417

       (2) If the director determines that the owner or operator is 1418
not in compliance with a permit or review compliance certificate1419
this chapter, rules adopted under it, or any terms and conditions 1420
of any permit issued under it or determines that a discharge of a 1421
pollutant is occurring or has occurred at the animal feeding 1422
operation, the director shall proceed in accordance with section 1423
903.16 or 903.17 of the Revised Code, or both, as applicable. 1424

       Sec. 903.16.  (A) The director of agriculture may propose to 1425
require corrective actions and assess a civil penalty against an 1426
owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding facility if the 1427
director or the director's authorized representative determines 1428
that the owner or operator is not in compliance with section 1429
903.02, 903.03, or 903.04 or division (A) of section 903.07 of the 1430
Revised Code, the terms and conditions of a permit to install, 1431
permit to operate, or review compliance certificate issued for the 1432
concentrated animal feeding facility, including the requirements 1433
established under division (C) of section 903.06 or division (A) 1434
of section 903.07 of the Revised Code, or rules adopted under 1435
division (A), (B), (C), (D), (E), or (J) of section 903.10 of the 1436
Revised Code. However, the director may impose a civil penalty 1437
only if all of the following occur: 1438

       (1) The owner or operator is notified in writing of the 1439
deficiencies resulting in noncompliance, the actions that the 1440
owner or operator must take to correct the deficiencies, and the 1441
time period within which the owner or operator must correct the 1442
deficiencies and attain compliance. 1443

       (2) After the time period specified in the notice has 1444
elapsed, the director or the director's duly authorized 1445
representative has inspected the concentrated animal feeding 1446
facility, determined that the owner or operator is still not in 1447
compliance, and issued a notice of an adjudication hearing. 1448

       (3) The director affords the owner or operator an opportunity 1449
for an adjudication hearing under Chapter 119. of the Revised 1450
Code to challenge the director's determination that the owner or 1451
operator is not in compliance or the imposition of the civil 1452
penalty, or both. However, the owner or operator may waive the 1453
right to an adjudication hearing. 1454

       (B) If the opportunity for an adjudication hearing is waived 1455
or if, after an adjudication hearing, the director determines that 1456
a violation has occurred or is occurring, the director may issue 1457
an order requiring compliance and assess the civil penalty. The 1458
order and the assessment of the civil penalty may be appealed in 1459
accordance with section 119.12 of the Revised Code. 1460

       Civil penalties shall be assessed under this division as 1461
follows: 1462

       (1) A person who has violated section 903.02, 903.03, or 1463
903.04 of the Revised Code, the terms and conditions of a permit 1464
to install, permit to operate, or review compliance certificate, 1465
or rules adopted under division (A), (B), (C), (D), (E), or (J) of 1466
section 903.10 of the Revised Code shall pay a civil penalty in an 1467
amount established in rules unless the violation is of the 1468
requirements established under division (C) of section 903.06 or 1469
division (A) of section 903.07 of the Revised Code. 1470

       (2) A person who has violated the requirements established 1471
under division (C) of section 903.06 of the Revised Code shall pay 1472
a civil penalty in an amount established in rules for each 1473
violation. Each seven-day period during which a violation 1474
continues constitutes a separate violation. 1475

       (3) A person who has violated the requirements established 1476
under division (A) of section 903.07 of the Revised Code shall pay 1477
a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand dollars for each 1478
violation. Each thirty-day period during which a violation 1479
continues constitutes a separate violation. 1480

       (C) The attorney general, upon the written request of the 1481
director, shall bring an action for an injunction in any court of 1482
competent jurisdiction against any person violating or threatening 1483
to violate section 903.02, 903.03, or 903.04 or division (A) of 1484
section 903.07 of the Revised Code; the terms and conditions of a 1485
permit to install, permit to operate, or review compliance 1486
certificate, including the requirements established under division 1487
(C) of section 903.06 or division (A) of section 903.07 of the 1488
Revised Code; rules adopted under division (A), (B), (C), (D), 1489
(E), or (J) of section 903.10 of the Revised Code; or an order 1490
issued under division (B) of this section or division (B) of 1491
section 903.07 of the Revised Code. 1492

       (D)(1) In lieu of seeking civil penalties under division (A) 1493
of this section, the director may request the attorney general, in 1494
writing, to bring an action for a civil penalty in a court of 1495
competent jurisdiction against any person that has violated or is 1496
violating division (A) of section 903.07 of the Revised Code or1497
the terms and conditions of a permit to install, permit to 1498
operate, or review compliance certificate, including the 1499
requirements established under division (C) of section 903.06 or 1500
division (A) of section 903.07 of the Revised Code. 1501

       (2) The director may request the attorney general, in 1502
writing, to bring an action for a civil penalty in a court of 1503
competent jurisdiction against any person that has violated or is 1504
violating section 903.02, 903.03, or 903.04 of the Revised Code, 1505
rules adopted under division (A), (B), (C), (D), (E), or (J) of 1506
section 903.10 of the Revised Code, or an order issued under 1507
division (B) of this section or division (B) of section 903.07 of 1508
the Revised Code. 1509

       (3) A person who has committed a violation for which the 1510
attorney general may bring an action for a civil penalty under 1511
division (D)(1) or (2) of this section shall pay a civil penalty 1512
of not more than ten thousand dollars per violation. Each day that 1513
a violation continues constitutes a separate violation. 1514

       (E) In addition to any other penalties imposed under this 1515
section, the director may impose an administrative penalty against 1516
an owner or operator of a concentrated animal feeding facility if 1517
the director or the director's authorized representative 1518
determines that the owner or operator is not in compliance with 1519
best management practices that are established in rules adopted 1520
under division (C) or (D) of section 903.10 of the Revised Code or 1521
in the permit to install, permit to operate, or review compliance 1522
certificate issued for the facility. The administrative penalty 1523
shall not exceed five thousand dollars.1524

        The director shall afford the owner or operator an 1525
opportunity for an adjudication hearing under Chapter 119. of the 1526
Revised Code to challenge the director's determination under this 1527
division, the director's imposition of an administrative penalty 1528
under this division, or both. The director's determination and the 1529
imposition of the administrative penalty may be appealed in 1530
accordance with section 119.12 of the Revised Code.1531

       Sec. 903.17.  (A) The director of agriculture may propose to 1532
require corrective actions and assess a civil penalty against an 1533
owner or operator of a point sourcean animal feeding operation if 1534
the director or the director's authorized representative 1535
determines that the owner or operator is not in compliance with 1536
section 903.08 of the Revised Code, the terms and conditions of a 1537
NPDES permit, the NPDES provisions of a permit to operate, or 1538
rules adopted under division (F) of section 903.10 of the Revised 1539
Code. However, the director may impose a civil penalty only if 1540
all of the following occur: 1541

       (1) The owner or operator is notified in writing of the 1542
deficiencies resulting in noncompliance, the actions that the 1543
owner or operator must take to correct the deficiencies, and the 1544
time period within which the owner or operator must correct the 1545
deficiencies and attain compliance. 1546

       (2) After the time period specified in the notice has 1547
elapsed, the director or the director's duly authorized 1548
representative has inspected the point sourceanimal feeding 1549
operation, determined that the owner or operator is still not in 1550
compliance, and issued a notice of violation to require 1551
corrective actions. 1552

       (3) The director affords the owner or operator an opportunity 1553
for an adjudication hearing under Chapter 119. of the Revised 1554
Code to challenge the director's determination that the owner or 1555
operator is not in compliance or the imposition of the civil 1556
penalty, or both. However, the owner or operator may waive the 1557
right to an adjudication hearing. 1558

       (B) If the opportunity for an adjudication hearing is waived 1559
or if, after an adjudication hearing, the director determines that 1560
a violation has occurred or is occurring, the director may issue 1561
an order and assess a civil penalty of not more than ten thousand 1562
dollars per violation against the violator. For purposes of 1563
determining the civil penalty, each day that a violation continues 1564
constitutes a separate and distinct violation. The order and the 1565
assessment of the civil penalty may be appealed in accordance with 1566
section 119.12 of the Revised Code. 1567

       (C) To the extent consistent with the Federal Water Pollution 1568
Control Act, the director shall consider technical feasibility and 1569
economic costs in issuing orders under this section. 1570

       (D)(1) The attorney general, upon the written request of the 1571
director, shall bring an action for an injunction in any court of 1572
competent jurisdiction against any person violating or threatening 1573
to violate section 903.08 of the Revised Code, the terms and 1574
conditions of a NPDES permit, the NPDES provisions of a permit to 1575
operate, rules adopted under division (F) of section 903.10 of the 1576
Revised Code, or an order issued under division (B) of this 1577
section. 1578

       (2) In lieu of seeking civil penalties under division (A) of 1579
this section, the director may request, in writing, the attorney 1580
general to bring an action for a civil penalty of not more than 1581
ten thousand dollars per violation in a court of competent 1582
jurisdiction against any person that has violated or is violating 1583
section 903.08 of the Revised Code, the terms and conditions of a 1584
NPDES permit, the NPDES provisions of a permit to operate, rules 1585
adopted under division (F) of section 903.10 of the Revised Code, 1586
or an order issued under division (B) of this section. For 1587
purposes of determining the civil penalty to be assessed under 1588
division (B) of this section, each day that a violation continues 1589
constitutes a separate and distinct violation. 1590

       (E) In addition to any other penalties imposed under this 1591
section, the director may impose an administrative penalty against 1592
an owner or operator of an animal feeding operation if the 1593
director or the director's authorized representative determines 1594
that the owner or operator has discharged pollutants into waters 1595
of the state in violation of section 903.08 of the Revised Code or 1596
the terms and conditions of a NPDES permit or the NPDES provisions 1597
of the permit to operate issued for the operation. The 1598
administrative penalty shall not exceed five thousand dollars.1599

        The director shall afford the owner or operator an 1600
opportunity for an adjudication hearing under Chapter 119. of the 1601
Revised Code to challenge the director's determination under this 1602
division, the director's imposition of an administrative penalty 1603
under this division, or both. The director's determination and the 1604
imposition of the administrative penalty may be appealed in 1605
accordance with section 119.12 of the Revised Code.1606

       Sec. 6111.03.  The director of environmental protection may 1607
do any of the following: 1608

       (A) Develop plans and programs for the prevention, control, 1609
and abatement of new or existing pollution of the waters of the 1610
state; 1611

       (B) Advise, consult, and cooperate with other agencies of the 1612
state, the federal government, other states, and interstate 1613
agencies and with affected groups, political subdivisions, and 1614
industries in furtherance of the purposes of this chapter. Before 1615
adopting, amending, or rescinding a standard or rule pursuant to 1616
division (G) of this section or section 6111.041 or 6111.042 of 1617
the Revised Code, the director shall do all of the following: 1618

       (1) Mail notice to each statewide organization that the 1619
director determines represents persons who would be affected by 1620
the proposed standard or rule, amendment thereto, or rescission 1621
thereof at least thirty-five days before any public hearing 1622
thereon; 1623

       (2) Mail a copy of each proposed standard or rule, amendment 1624
thereto, or rescission thereof to any person who requests a copy, 1625
within five days after receipt of the request therefor; 1626

       (3) Consult with appropriate state and local government 1627
agencies or their representatives, including statewide 1628
organizations of local government officials, industrial 1629
representatives, and other interested persons. 1630

       Although the director is expected to discharge these duties 1631
diligently, failure to mail any such notice or copy or to so 1632
consult with any person shall not invalidate any proceeding or 1633
action of the director. 1634

       (C) Administer grants from the federal government and from 1635
other sources, public or private, for carrying out any of its 1636
functions, all such moneys to be deposited in the state treasury 1637
and kept by the treasurer of state in a separate fund subject to 1638
the lawful orders of the director; 1639

       (D) Administer state grants for the construction of sewage 1640
and waste collection and treatment works; 1641

       (E) Encourage, participate in, or conduct studies, 1642
investigations, research, and demonstrations relating to water 1643
pollution, and the causes, prevention, control, and abatement 1644
thereof, that are advisable and necessary for the discharge of the 1645
director's duties under this chapter; 1646

       (F) Collect and disseminate information relating to water 1647
pollution and prevention, control, and abatement thereof; 1648

       (G) Adopt, amend, and rescind rules in accordance with 1649
Chapter 119. of the Revised Code governing the procedure for 1650
hearings, the filing of reports, the issuance of permits, the 1651
issuance of industrial water pollution control certificates, and 1652
all other matters relating to procedure; 1653

       (H) Issue, modify, or revoke orders to prevent, control, or 1654
abate water pollution by such means as the following: 1655

       (1) Prohibiting or abating discharges of sewage, industrial 1656
waste, or other wastes into the waters of the state; 1657

       (2) Requiring the construction of new disposal systems or any 1658
parts thereof, or the modification, extension, or alteration of 1659
existing disposal systems or any parts thereof; 1660

       (3) Prohibiting additional connections to or extensions of a 1661
sewerage system when the connections or extensions would result in 1662
an increase in the polluting properties of the effluent from the 1663
system when discharged into any waters of the state; 1664

       (4) Requiring compliance with any standard or rule adopted 1665
under sections 6111.01 to 6111.05 of the Revised Code or term or 1666
condition of a permit. 1667

       In the making of those orders, wherever compliance with a 1668
rule adopted under section 6111.042 of the Revised Code is not 1669
involved, consistent with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 1670
the director shall give consideration to, and base the 1671
determination on, evidence relating to the technical feasibility 1672
and economic reasonableness of complying with those orders and to 1673
evidence relating to conditions calculated to result from 1674
compliance with those orders, and their relation to benefits to 1675
the people of the state to be derived from such compliance in 1676
accomplishing the purposes of this chapter. 1677

       (I) Review plans, specifications, or other data relative to 1678
disposal systems or any part thereof in connection with the 1679
issuance of orders, permits, and industrial water pollution 1680
control certificates under this chapter; 1681

       (J)(1) Issue, revoke, modify, or deny sludge management 1682
permits and permits for the discharge of sewage, industrial waste, 1683
or other wastes into the waters of the state, and for the 1684
installation or modification of disposal systems or any parts 1685
thereof in compliance with all requirements of the Federal Water 1686
Pollution Control Act and mandatory regulations adopted 1687
thereunder, including regulations adopted under section 405 of the 1688
Federal Water Pollution Control Act, and set terms and conditions 1689
of permits, including schedules of compliance, where necessary. 1690
Any person who discharges, transports, or handles storm water from 1691
an animal feeding facility, as defined in section 903.01 of the 1692
Revised Code, or manurepollutants from a concentrated animal 1693
feeding operation, as both terms are defined in that section, is 1694
not required to obtain a permit under division (J)(1) of this 1695
section for the installation or modification of a disposal system 1696
involving manurepollutants or storm water or any parts of such a 1697
system on and after the date on which the director of agriculture 1698
has finalized the program required under division (A)(1) of 1699
section 903.02 of the Revised Code. In addition, any person who 1700
discharges, transports, or handles storm water from an animal 1701
feeding facility, as defined in section 903.01 of the revised code1702
Revised Code, or manurepollutants from a concentrated animal 1703
feeding operation, as both terms are defined in that section, is 1704
not required to obtain a permit under division (J)(1) of this 1705
section for the discharge of storm water from an animal feeding 1706
facility or manurepollutants from a concentrated animal feeding 1707
operation on and after the date on which the United States 1708
environmental protection agency approves the NPDES program 1709
submitted by the director of agriculture under section 903.08 of 1710
the Revised Code. 1711

       Any permit terms and conditions set by the director shall be 1712
designed to achieve and maintain full compliance with the national 1713
effluent limitations, national standards of performance for new 1714
sources, and national toxic and pretreatment effluent standards 1715
set under that act, and any other mandatory requirements of that 1716
act that are imposed by regulation of the administrator of the 1717
United States environmental protection agency. If an applicant for 1718
a sludge management permit also applies for a related permit for 1719
the discharge of sewage, industrial waste, or other wastes into 1720
the waters of the state, the director may combine the two permits 1721
and issue one permit to the applicant. 1722

       A sludge management permit is not required for an entity that 1723
treats or transports sewage sludge or for a sanitary landfill when 1724
all of the following apply: 1725

       (a) The entity or sanitary landfill does not generate the 1726
sewage sludge. 1727

       (b) Prior to receipt at the sanitary landfill, the entity has 1728
ensured that the sewage sludge meets the requirements established 1729
in rules adopted by the director under section 3734.02 of the 1730
Revised Code concerning disposal of municipal solid waste in a 1731
sanitary landfill. 1732

       (c) Disposal of the sewage sludge occurs at a sanitary 1733
landfill that complies with rules adopted by the director under 1734
section 3734.02 of the Revised Code. 1735

       As used in division (J)(1) of this section, "sanitary 1736
landfill" means a sanitary landfill facility, as defined in rules 1737
adopted under section 3734.02 of the Revised Code, that is 1738
licensed as a solid waste facility under section 3734.05 of the 1739
Revised Code. 1740

       (2) An application for a permit or renewal thereof shall be 1741
denied if any of the following applies: 1742

       (a) The secretary of the army determines in writing that 1743
anchorage or navigation would be substantially impaired thereby; 1744

       (b) The director determines that the proposed discharge or 1745
source would conflict with an areawide waste treatment management 1746
plan adopted in accordance with section 208 of the Federal Water 1747
Pollution Control Act; 1748

       (c) The administrator of the United States environmental 1749
protection agency objects in writing to the issuance or renewal of 1750
the permit in accordance with section 402 (d) of the Federal Water 1751
Pollution Control Act; 1752

       (d) The application is for the discharge of any radiological, 1753
chemical, or biological warfare agent or high-level radioactive 1754
waste into the waters of the United States. 1755

       (3) To achieve and maintain applicable standards of quality 1756
for the waters of the state adopted pursuant to section 6111.041 1757
of the Revised Code, the director shall impose, where necessary 1758
and appropriate, as conditions of each permit, water quality 1759
related effluent limitations in accordance with sections 301, 302, 1760
306, 307, and 405 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and, 1761
to the extent consistent with that act, shall give consideration 1762
to, and base the determination on, evidence relating to the 1763
technical feasibility and economic reasonableness of removing the 1764
polluting properties from those wastes and to evidence relating to 1765
conditions calculated to result from that action and their 1766
relation to benefits to the people of the state and to 1767
accomplishment of the purposes of this chapter. 1768

       (4) Where a discharge having a thermal component from a 1769
source that is constructed or modified on or after October 18, 1770
1972, meets national or state effluent limitations or more 1771
stringent permit conditions designed to achieve and maintain 1772
compliance with applicable standards of quality for the waters of 1773
the state, which limitations or conditions will ensure protection 1774
and propagation of a balanced, indigenous population of shellfish, 1775
fish, and wildlife in or on the body of water into which the 1776
discharge is made, taking into account the interaction of the 1777
thermal component with sewage, industrial waste, or other wastes, 1778
the director shall not impose any more stringent limitation on the 1779
thermal component of the discharge, as a condition of a permit or 1780
renewal thereof for the discharge, during a ten-year period 1781
beginning on the date of completion of the construction or 1782
modification of the source, or during the period of depreciation 1783
or amortization of the source for the purpose of section 167 or 1784
169 of the Internal Revenue Code of 1954, whichever period ends 1785
first. 1786

       (5) The director shall specify in permits for the discharge 1787
of sewage, industrial waste, and other wastes, the net volume, net 1788
weight, duration, frequency, and, where necessary, concentration 1789
of the sewage, industrial waste, and other wastes that may be 1790
discharged into the waters of the state. The director shall 1791
specify in those permits and in sludge management permits that the 1792
permit is conditioned upon payment of applicable fees as required 1793
by section 3745.11 of the Revised Code and upon the right of the 1794
director's authorized representatives to enter upon the premises 1795
of the person to whom the permit has been issued for the purpose 1796
of determining compliance with this chapter, rules adopted 1797
thereunder, or the terms and conditions of a permit, order, or 1798
other determination. The director shall issue or deny an 1799
application for a sludge management permit or a permit for a new 1800
discharge, for the installation or modification of a disposal 1801
system, or for the renewal of a permit, within one hundred eighty 1802
days of the date on which a complete application with all plans, 1803
specifications, construction schedules, and other pertinent 1804
information required by the director is received. 1805

       (6) The director may condition permits upon the installation 1806
of discharge or water quality monitoring equipment or devices and 1807
the filing of periodic reports on the amounts and contents of 1808
discharges and the quality of receiving waters that the director 1809
prescribes. The director shall condition each permit for a 1810
government-owned disposal system or any other "treatment works" as 1811
defined in the Federal Water Pollution Control Act upon the 1812
reporting of new introductions of industrial waste or other wastes 1813
and substantial changes in volume or character thereof being 1814
introduced into those systems or works from "industrial users" as 1815
defined in section 502 of that act, as necessary to comply with 1816
section 402(b)(8) of that act; upon the identification of the 1817
character and volume of pollutants subject to pretreatment 1818
standards being introduced into the system or works; and upon the 1819
existence of a program to ensure compliance with pretreatment 1820
standards by "industrial users" of the system or works. In 1821
requiring monitoring devices and reports, the director, to the 1822
extent consistent with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, 1823
shall give consideration to technical feasibility and economic 1824
reasonableness and shall allow reasonable time for compliance. 1825

       (7) A permit may be issued for a period not to exceed five 1826
years and may be renewed upon application for renewal and upon a 1827
finding by the director that the permit holder is making 1828
satisfactory progress toward the achievement of all applicable 1829
standards and has complied with the terms and conditions of the 1830
existing permit. A permit may be modified, suspended, or revoked 1831
for cause, including, but not limited to, violation of any 1832
condition of the permit, obtaining a permit by misrepresentation 1833
or failure to disclose fully all relevant facts of the permitted 1834
discharge or of the sludge use, storage, treatment, or disposal 1835
practice, or changes in any condition that requires either a 1836
temporary or permanent reduction or elimination of the permitted 1837
activity. No application shall be denied or permit revoked or 1838
modified without a written order stating the findings upon which 1839
the denial, revocation, or modification is based. A copy of the 1840
order shall be sent to the applicant or permit holder by certified 1841
mail. 1842

       (K) Institute or cause to be instituted in any court of 1843
competent jurisdiction proceedings to compel compliance with this 1844
chapter or with the orders of the director issued under this 1845
chapter, or to ensure compliance with sections 204(b), 307, 308, 1846
and 405 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act; 1847

       (L) Issue, deny, revoke, or modify industrial water pollution 1848
control certificates; 1849

       (M) Certify to the government of the United States or any 1850
agency thereof that an industrial water pollution control facility 1851
is in conformity with the state program or requirements for the 1852
control of water pollution whenever the certification may be 1853
required for a taxpayer under the Internal Revenue Code of the 1854
United States, as amended; 1855

       (N) Issue, modify, and revoke orders requiring any 1856
"industrial user" of any publicly owned "treatment works" as 1857
defined in sections 212(2) and 502(18) of the Federal Water 1858
Pollution Control Act to comply with pretreatment standards; 1859
establish and maintain records; make reports; install, use, and 1860
maintain monitoring equipment or methods, including, where 1861
appropriate, biological monitoring methods; sample discharges in 1862
accordance with methods, at locations, at intervals, and in a 1863
manner that the director determines; and provide other information 1864
that is necessary to ascertain whether or not there is compliance 1865
with toxic and pretreatment effluent standards. In issuing, 1866
modifying, and revoking those orders, the director, to the extent 1867
consistent with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act, shall 1868
give consideration to technical feasibility and economic 1869
reasonableness and shall allow reasonable time for compliance. 1870

       (O) Exercise all incidental powers necessary to carry out the 1871
purposes of this chapter; 1872

       (P) Certify or deny certification to any applicant for a 1873
federal license or permit to conduct any activity that may result 1874
in any discharge into the waters of the state that the discharge 1875
will comply with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act; 1876

       (Q) Administer and enforce the publicly owned treatment works 1877
pretreatment program in accordance with the Federal Water 1878
Pollution Control Act. In the administration of that program, the 1879
director may do any of the following: 1880

       (1) Apply and enforce pretreatment standards; 1881

       (2) Approve and deny requests for approval of publicly owned 1882
treatment works pretreatment programs, oversee those programs, and 1883
implement, in whole or in part, those programs under any of the 1884
following conditions: 1885

       (a) The director has denied a request for approval of the 1886
publicly owned treatment works pretreatment program; 1887

       (b) The director has revoked the publicly owned treatment 1888
works pretreatment program; 1889

       (c) There is no pretreatment program currently being 1890
implemented by the publicly owned treatment works; 1891

       (d) The publicly owned treatment works has requested the 1892
director to implement, in whole or in part, the pretreatment 1893
program. 1894

       (3) Require that a publicly owned treatment works 1895
pretreatment program be incorporated in a permit issued to a 1896
publicly owned treatment works as required by the Federal Water 1897
Pollution Control Act, require compliance by publicly owned 1898
treatment works with those programs, and require compliance by 1899
industrial users with pretreatment standards; 1900

       (4) Approve and deny requests for authority to modify 1901
categorical pretreatment standards to reflect removal of 1902
pollutants achieved by publicly owned treatment works; 1903

       (5) Deny and recommend approval of requests for fundamentally 1904
different factors variances submitted by industrial users; 1905

       (6) Make determinations on categorization of industrial 1906
users; 1907

       (7) Adopt, amend, or rescind rules and issue, modify, or 1908
revoke orders necessary for the administration and enforcement of 1909
the publicly owned treatment works pretreatment program. 1910

       Any approval of a publicly owned treatment works pretreatment 1911
program may contain any terms and conditions, including schedules 1912
of compliance, that are necessary to achieve compliance with this 1913
chapter. 1914

       (R) Except as otherwise provided in this division, adopt 1915
rules in accordance with Chapter 119. of the Revised Code 1916
establishing procedures, methods, and equipment and other 1917
requirements for equipment to prevent and contain discharges of 1918
oil and hazardous substances into the waters of the state. The 1919
rules shall be consistent with and equivalent in scope, content, 1920
and coverage to section 311(j)(1)(c) of the Federal Water 1921
Pollution Control Act and regulations adopted under it. The 1922
director shall not adopt rules under this division relating to 1923
discharges of oil from oil production facilities and oil drilling 1924
and workover facilities as those terms are defined in that act and 1925
regulations adopted under it. 1926

       (S)(1) Administer and enforce a program for the regulation of 1927
sludge management in this state. In administering the program, 1928
the director, in addition to exercising the authority provided in 1929
any other applicable sections of this chapter, may do any of the 1930
following: 1931

       (a) Develop plans and programs for the disposal and 1932
utilization of sludge and sludge materials; 1933

       (b) Encourage, participate in, or conduct studies, 1934
investigations, research, and demonstrations relating to the 1935
disposal and use of sludge and sludge materials and the impact of 1936
sludge and sludge materials on land located in the state and on 1937
the air and waters of the state; 1938

       (c) Collect and disseminate information relating to the 1939
disposal and use of sludge and sludge materials and the impact of 1940
sludge and sludge materials on land located in the state and on 1941
the air and waters of the state; 1942

       (d) Issue, modify, or revoke orders to prevent, control, or 1943
abate the use and disposal of sludge and sludge materials or the 1944
effects of the use of sludge and sludge materials on land located 1945
in the state and on the air and waters of the state; 1946

       (e) Adopt and enforce, modify, or rescind rules necessary for 1947
the implementation of division (S) of this section. The rules 1948
reasonably shall protect public health and the environment, 1949
encourage the beneficial reuse of sludge and sludge materials, and 1950
minimize the creation of nuisance odors. 1951

       The director may specify in sludge management permits the net 1952
volume, net weight, quality, and pollutant concentration of the 1953
sludge or sludge materials that may be used, stored, treated, or 1954
disposed of, and the manner and frequency of the use, storage, 1955
treatment, or disposal, to protect public health and the 1956
environment from adverse effects relating to those activities. The 1957
director shall impose other terms and conditions to protect public 1958
health and the environment, minimize the creation of nuisance 1959
odors, and achieve compliance with this chapter and rules adopted 1960
under it and, in doing so, shall consider whether the terms and 1961
conditions are consistent with the goal of encouraging the 1962
beneficial reuse of sludge and sludge materials. 1963

       The director may condition permits on the implementation of 1964
treatment, storage, disposal, distribution, or application 1965
management methods and the filing of periodic reports on the 1966
amounts, composition, and quality of sludge and sludge materials 1967
that are disposed of, used, treated, or stored. 1968

       An approval of a treatment works sludge disposal program may 1969
contain any terms and conditions, including schedules of 1970
compliance, necessary to achieve compliance with this chapter and 1971
rules adopted under it. 1972

       (2) As a part of the program established under division 1973
(S)(1) of this section, the director has exclusive authority to 1974
regulate sewage sludge management in this state. For purposes of 1975
division (S)(2) of this section, that program shall be consistent 1976
with section 405 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and 1977
regulations adopted under it and with this section, except that 1978
the director may adopt rules under division (S) of this section 1979
that establish requirements that are more stringent than section 1980
405 of the Federal Water Pollution Control Act and regulations 1981
adopted under it with regard to monitoring sewage sludge and 1982
sewage sludge materials and establishing acceptable sewage sludge 1983
management practices and pollutant levels in sewage sludge and 1984
sewage sludge materials. 1985

       This chapter authorizes the state to participate in any 1986
national sludge management program and the national pollutant 1987
discharge elimination system, to administer and enforce the 1988
publicly owned treatment works pretreatment program, and to issue 1989
permits for the discharge of dredged or fill materials, in 1990
accordance with the Federal Water Pollution Control Act. This 1991
chapter shall be administered, consistent with the laws of this 1992
state and federal law, in the same manner that the Federal Water 1993
Pollution Control Act is required to be administered. 1994

       This section does not apply to animal waste disposal systems 1995
and related management and conservation practices subject to rules 1996
adopted pursuant to division (E)(4) of section 1511.02 of the 1997
Revised Code. However, until the date on which the United States 1998
environmental protection agency approves the NPDES program 1999
submitted by the director of agriculture under section 903.08 of 2000
the Revised Code, this exclusion does not apply to animal waste 2001
treatment works having a controlled direct discharge to the waters 2002
of the state or any concentrated animal feeding operation, as 2003
defined in 40 C.F.R. 122.23(b)(2). On and after the date on which 2004
the United States environmental protection agency approves the 2005
NPDES program submitted by the director of agriculture under 2006
section 903.08 of the Revised Code, this section does not apply to 2007
storm water from an animal feeding facility, as defined in section 2008
903.01 of the Revised Code, or to manurepollutants discharged 2009
from a concentrated animal feeding operation, as both terms are2010
defined in that section. Neither of these exclusions applies to 2011
the discharge of animal waste into a publicly owned treatment 2012
works. 2013

       Section 2. That existing sections 903.01, 903.02, 903.03, 2014
903.04, 903.05, 903.06, 903.07, 903.08, 903.081, 903.082, 903.09, 2015
903.10, 903.15, 903.16, 903.17, and 6111.03 of the Revised Code 2016
are hereby repealed. 2017

       Section 3. The amendments by this act of divisions (C)(1) and 2018
(H) of section 903.02; divisions (A), (C)(1), and (I) of section 2019
903.03; divisions (D) and (E)(2)(a) of section 903.04; sections 2020
903.05, 903.06, and 903.07; divisions (A)(2) to (14) and (E) of 2021
section 903.10; section 903.16; and division (E) of section 903.17 2022
of the Revised Code become operative on the date on which the 2023
Administrator of the United States Environmental Protection Agency 2024
approves the National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System 2025
program submitted by the Director of Agriculture under section 2026
903.08 of the Revised Code as amended by this act.2027

       Section 4. That Section 640.24 of Am. Sub. H.B. 1 of the 2028
128th General Assembly be amended to read as follows:2029

       Sec. 640.24. Sections 640.22 and 640.23 take effect on 2030
JanuaryJuly 1, 2010.2031

       Section 5.  That existing Section 640.24 of Am. Sub. H.B. 1 2032
of the 128th General Assembly is hereby repealed.2033

       Section 6.  That Sections 120.01 and 120.02 of Am. Sub. H.B. 2034
119 of the 127th General Assembly, as amended by Am. Sub. H.B. 1 2035
of the 128th General Assembly, be amended to read as follows:2036

       Sec. 120.01. During the period beginning July 1, 2007, and 2037
expiring JanuaryJuly 1, 2010, the operation of sections 3718.02, 2038
3718.05, 3718.06, 3718.07, 3718.08, 3718.09, 3718.10, 3718.99, and 2039
6111.441 of the Revised Code is suspended. On JanuaryJuly 1, 2040
2010, sections 3718.02, 3718.05, 3718.06, 3718.07, 3718.08, 2041
3718.09, 3718.10, 3718.99, and 6111.441 of the Revised Code, in 2042
either their present form or as they are later amended by this 2043
act or any other act, again become operational.2044

       Sec. 120.02. (A)(1) Effective July 2, 2007, the rules adopted 2045
by the Public Health Council under section 3718.02 of the Revised 2046
Code that took effect on January 1, 2007, are not valid. Not later 2047
than July 2, 2007, the Director of Health shall adopt rules that 2048
are identical to the rules adopted by the Public Health Council 2049
that were in effect prior to January 1, 2007, and were codified in 2050
Chapter 3701-29 of the Administrative Code, except the rules in 2051
that chapter that established requirements for separation 2052
distances from a water table and soil absorption requirements.2053

       At the same time that the Public Health Council adopts the 2054
rules required under division (A)(2) of this section, the Director 2055
shall rescind the rules adopted under this division.2056

       The adoption and rescission of rules under this division are 2057
not subject to section 119.03 of the Revised Code. However, the 2058
Director shall file the adoption and rescission of the rules in 2059
accordance with section 119.04 of the Revised Code. Upon that 2060
filing, the adoption and rescission of the rules take immediate 2061
effect.2062

       (2) Not later than thirty days after the effective date of 2063
this section as enacted by Am. Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th General 2064
Assembly and notwithstanding any provision of law to the contrary, 2065
the Public Health Council shall rescind rules adopted by the 2066
Council under section 3718.02 of the Revised Code, that took 2067
effect on January 1, 2007. At the same time as those rules are 2068
rescinded, the Council shall adopt rules that are identical to the 2069
rules adopted by the Council that were in effect prior to January 2070
1, 2007, and were codified in Chapter 3701-29 of the 2071
Administrative Code, except the rules in that Chapter that 2072
established requirements for separation distances from a water 2073
table and soil absorption requirements. Instead, a board of health 2074
or the authority having the duties of a board of health shall 2075
adopt standards establishing requirements for separation distances 2076
from a water table and soil absorption requirements based on the 2077
water table and soils in the applicable health district for 2078
purposes of the installation and operation of household sewage 2079
treatment systems and small flow on-site sewage treatment systems 2080
in the applicable health district.2081

       The rescission and adoption of rules under this division are 2082
not subject to section 119.03 of the Revised Code. However, the 2083
Public Health Council shall file the rules in accordance with 2084
section 119.04 of the Revised Code. Upon that filing, the rules 2085
take immediate effect.2086

       (B) A local board of health or the authority having the 2087
duties of a board of health may adopt standards for use in the 2088
health district that are more stringent than the rules adopted 2089
under division (A)(1) or (2) of this section, provided that the 2090
board of health or authority having the duties of a board of 2091
health in adopting such standards considers the economic impact of 2092
those standards on property owners, the state of available 2093
technology, and the nature and economics of the available 2094
alternatives. If a board of health or authority having the duties 2095
of a board of health adopts standards that are more stringent than 2096
the rules adopted under division (A)(1) or (2) of this section, 2097
the board or authority shall send a copy of the standards to the 2098
Department of Health.2099

       (C)(1) A board of health or the authority having the duties 2100
of a board of health shall approve or deny the use of household 2101
sewage treatment systems and small flow on-site sewage treatment 2102
systems in the applicable health district. In approving or denying 2103
a household sewage treatment system or a small flow on-site sewage 2104
treatment system for use in the health district, the board or 2105
authority shall consider the economic impact of the system on 2106
property owners, the state of available technology, and the nature 2107
and economics of the available alternatives, ensure that a system 2108
will not create a public health nuisance, and require a system to 2109
comply with the requirements established in divisions (C)(2) and 2110
(3) of this section.2111

       (2) Notwithstanding any rule adopted by the Director of 2112
Health or the Public Health Council or standard adopted by a board 2113
of health or the authority having the duties of a board of health 2114
governing the installation and operation of sewage treatment 2115
systems, a board of health or the authority having the duties of a 2116
board of health shall ensure that the design and installation of a 2117
soil absorption system prevents public health nuisances. To the 2118
extent determined necessary by a board of health or the authority 2119
having the duties of a board of health, a sewage treatment system 2120
that is installed after the effective date of this section as 2121
enacted by Am. Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th General Assembly shall 2122
not discharge to a ditch, stream, pond, lake, natural or 2123
artificial waterway, drain tile, other surface water, or the 2124
surface of the ground unless authorized by a national pollutant 2125
discharge elimination system (NPDES) permit issued under Chapter 2126
6111. of the Revised Code and rules adopted under it. In addition, 2127
a sewage treatment system shall not discharge to an abandoned 2128
well, a drainage well, a dry well or cesspool, a sinkhole, or 2129
another connection to ground water. As a condition to the issuance 2130
of a permit to operate a system, a board of health or the 2131
authority having the duties of a board of health shall require a 2132
service contract for any sewage treatment system that is subject 2133
to an NPDES permit to the extent required by the Environmental 2134
Protection Agency. If classified as a class V injection well, a 2135
household sewage treatment system serving a two- or three-family 2136
dwelling or a small flow on-site sewage treatment system shall 2137
comply with 40 C.F.R. 144, as published in the July 1, 2005, Code 2138
of Federal Regulations and with the registration requirements 2139
established in rule 3745-34-13 of the Administrative Code.2140

       (3) Notwithstanding any rule adopted by the Director of 2141
Health or the Public Health Council or standard adopted by a board 2142
of health or the authority having the duties of a board of health 2143
governing the installation and operation of household sewage 2144
treatment systems, all septic tanks, other disposal component 2145
tanks, dosing tanks, pump vaults, household sewage disposal system 2146
holding tanks and privy vaults, or other applicable sewage 2147
disposal system components manufactured after the effective date 2148
of this section as enacted by Am. Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th 2149
General Assembly and used in this state shall be watertight and 2150
structurally sound.2151

       (4) For purposes of division (C) of this section, "economic 2152
impact" means all of the following with respect to the approval or 2153
denial of a household sewage treatment system or small flow 2154
on-site sewage treatment system, as applicable:2155

       (a) The cost of a proposed system;2156

       (b) The cost of an alternative system that will not create a 2157
public health nuisance;2158

       (c) A comparison of the costs of repairing a system as 2159
opposed to replacing the system with a new system;2160

       (d) The value of the dwelling or facility, as applicable, 2161
that the system services as indicated in the most recent tax 2162
duplicate.2163

       (D)(1) Notwithstanding any rule adopted by the Director of 2164
Health or the Public Health Council governing the installation and 2165
operation of household sewage treatment systems, a board of health 2166
or the authority having the duties of a board of health may 2167
establish and collect fees for the purposes of this section.2168

       (2) In addition to the fees that are authorized to be 2169
established under division (D)(1) of this section, there is hereby 2170
levied an application fee of twenty-five dollars for a sewage 2171
treatment system installation permit. A board of health or the 2172
authority having the duties of a board of health shall collect the 2173
fee on behalf of the Department of Health and forward the fee to 2174
the Department to be deposited in the state treasury to the credit 2175
of the Sewage Treatment System Innovation Fund, which is hereby 2176
created. Not more than seventy-five per cent of the money in the 2177
Fund shall be used by the Department to administer the sewage 2178
treatment system program, and not less than twenty-five per cent 2179
of the money in the Fund shall be used to establish a grant 2180
program in cooperation with boards of health to fund the 2181
installation and evaluation of new technology pilot projects. In 2182
the selection of the pilot projects, the Director of Health shall 2183
consult with the Sewage Treatment System Technical Advisory 2184
Committee created in section 3718.03 of the Revised Code.2185

       (E) Not later than one year after the installation of a 2186
household sewage treatment system, a board of health or the 2187
authority having the duties of a board of health shall inspect the 2188
system to ensure that it is not a public health nuisance.2189

       (F) The Department of Health may file an injunctive action 2190
against a board of health or the authority having the duties of a 2191
board of health that allows a household sewage treatment system or 2192
small flow on-site sewage treatment system to cause a public 2193
health nuisance, provided that the Department provides reasonable 2194
notice to the board or authority and allows for the opportunity to 2195
abate the nuisance prior to the action.2196

       (G) The Environmental Protection Agency shall not require a 2197
board of health or the authority having the duties of a board of 2198
health to enter into a memorandum of understanding or any other 2199
agreement with the Agency regarding the issuance of NPDES permits 2200
for off-lot sewage treatment systems. Instead, a representative of 2201
a board of health or the authority having the duties of a board of 2202
health may meet with a person who intends to install such a system 2203
to determine the feasibility of the system and refer the person to 2204
the Agency to secure an NPDES permit for the system if needed. The 2205
Environmental Protection Agency, within ninety days or as quickly 2206
as possible after the effective date of this section as enacted by 2207
Am. Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th General Assembly, shall seek a 2208
revision to the general NPDES permit, issued pursuant to the 2209
federal Water Pollution Control Act as defined in section 6111.01 2210
of the Revised Code, in order not to require a memorandum of 2211
understanding with a board of health or the authority having the 2212
duties of a board of health and that allows a property owner to 2213
seek coverage under the general NPDES permit for purposes of this 2214
division. A board of health or the authority having the duties of 2215
a board of health voluntarily may enter into a memorandum of 2216
understanding with the Environmental Protection Agency to 2217
implement the general NPDES permit. In the interim, the Agency 2218
shall work with boards of health or authorities having the duties 2219
of boards of health and with property owners in order to 2220
facilitate the owners' securing an NPDES permit in counties 2221
without a memorandum of understanding.2222

       (H) Notwithstanding any rule adopted by the Director of 2223
Health or the Public Health Council governing the installation and 2224
operation of household sewage treatment systems, a board of health 2225
or the authority having the duties of a board of health that, 2226
prior to the effective date of this section, has obtained 2227
authority from the Department of Health and the Environmental 2228
Protection Agency to regulate small flow on-site sewage treatment 2229
systems may continue to regulate such systems on and after the 2230
effective date of this section as enacted by Am. Sub. H.B. 119 of 2231
the 127th General Assembly. A board of health or the authority 2232
having the duties of a board of health that has not obtained such 2233
authority may request the authority from the Department of Health 2234
and the Environmental Protection Agency in the manner provided by 2235
law.2236

       (I) Because the rules adopted by the Public Health Council 2237
under section 3718.02 of the Revised Code that were effective on 2238
January 1, 2007, have been rescinded by operation of this section, 2239
the references to those rules in section 3718.021 of the Revised 2240
Code are not operable. Instead, notwithstanding any other 2241
provisions of this section, the Director of Health or the Public 2242
Health Council, as applicable, shall provide for the 2243
implementation of section 3718.021 of the Revised Code in the 2244
rules that are required to be adopted under division (A) of this 2245
section.2246

       (J) The Department of Health in cooperation with a board of 2247
health or the authority having the duties of a board of health 2248
shall assess the familiarity of the board's or authority's staff 2249
with the best practices in the use of sewage treatment systems and 2250
conduct appropriate training to educate the board's or authority's 2251
staff in those best practices and in the use of any new sewage 2252
treatment system technology that is recommended for use by the 2253
Sewage Treatment System Technical Advisory Committee created in 2254
section 3718.03 of the Revised Code.2255

       (K)(1) As used in this section, "household sewage treatment 2256
system," "small flow on-site sewage treatment system," and "sewage 2257
treatment system" have the same meanings as in section 3718.01 of 2258
the Revised Code.2259

       (2) For the purposes of this section, "household sewage 2260
treatment system" is deemed to mean "household sewage disposal 2261
system" as necessary for the operation of this section.2262

       (3) For purposes of this section, a public health nuisance 2263
shall be deemed to exist when an inspection conducted by a board 2264
of health documents odor, color, or other visual manifestations of 2265
raw or poorly treated sewage and either of the following applies:2266

       (a) Water samples exceed five thousand fecal coliform counts 2267
per one hundred milliliters (either MPN or MF) in two or more 2268
samples when five or fewer samples are collected or in more than 2269
twenty per cent of the samples when more than five samples are 2270
taken.2271

       (b) Water samples exceed five hundred seventy-six E. Coli 2272
counts per one hundred milliliters in two or more samples when 2273
five or fewer samples are collected or in more than twenty per 2274
cent of the samples when more than five samples are taken.2275

       (L) Neither the Director of Health or the Public Health 2276
Council shall adopt rules prior to JanuaryJuly 1, 2010, that 2277
modify or change the requirements established by this section.2278

       (M) This section expires on the effective date of the rules 2279
that are to be adopted under section 3718.02 of the Revised Code 2280
when that section becomes operational on JanuaryJuly 1, 2010, 2281
pursuant to Section 120.01 of Am. Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th 2282
General Assembly, as amended."2283

       Section 7.  That existing Sections 120.01 and 120.02 of Am. 2284
Sub. H.B. 119 of the 127th General Assembly, as amended by Am. 2285
Sub. H.B. 1 of the 128th General Assembly, are hereby repealed.2286

       Section 8. This act is hereby declared to be an emergency 2287
measure necessary for the immediate preservation of the public 2288
peace, health, and safety. The reason for such necessity is to 2289
expedite the process of receiving approval from the Administrator 2290
of the United States Environmental Protection Agency for the 2291
Director of Agriculture to administer certain national pollutant 2292
discharge elimination system permits and to provide for the 2293
extension of temporary provisions governing sewage treatment 2294
systems to provide time for the General Assembly to craft new 2295
requirements pertaining to those systems. Therefore, this act 2296
shall go into immediate effect.2297