As Introduced

128th General Assembly
Regular Session
2009-2010
S. B. No. 149


Senator Strahorn 

Cosponsors: Senators Cafaro, Miller, D., Turner, Kearney, Miller, R., Morano, Goodman 



A BILL
To enact sections 185.01, 185.02, 185.021, and 185.03 1
to 185.07 of the Revised Code to establish 2
procedures for the Ohio Civil Rights Commission 3
to extend state recognition to native American 4
tribes, native American groups, and native 5
American special interest groups, and to specify 6
the rights, duties, and responsibilities of any 7
native American tribe that the Commission 8
recognizes and to extend such state recognition to 9
the Shawnee Nation United Remnant Band. 10


BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF OHIO:

       Section 1. That sections 185.01, 185.02, 185.021, 185.03, 11
185.04, 185.05, 185.06, and 185.07 of the Revised Code be enacted 12
to read as follows: 13

       Sec. 185.01.  As used in this chapter:14

       (A) "Native American tribe" means any native American tribe, 15
band, nation, or other organized group or community that is 16
indigenous to the contiguous land area of this state, that has 17
had a continuous presence inside that contiguous land area, and 18
that meets the other criteria for recognition contained in 19
section 185.05 of the Revised Code.20

       (B) "Native American group" means any native American 21
aggregated entity that does not claim to be a native American 22
tribe.23

       (C) "Native American special interest group" means any native 24
American aggregated entity that is formed with the intent to 25
petition, campaign, promote, or otherwise advocate for an issue 26
or constituency.27

       Sec. 185.02.  (A) The Ohio civil rights commission shall 28
adopt and may amend and rescind rules that are necessary to 29
provide for state recognition of native American tribes, native 30
American groups, or native American special interest groups.31

       (B) The commission shall confer state recognition on a native 32
American tribe in accordance with the criteria for recognition 33
contained in section 185.05 of the Revised Code.34

       Sec. 185.021. This state confers state recognition upon the 35
Shawnee nation united remnant band based on the findings stated in 36
Am. Sub. H.J.R. 8 of the 113th general assembly.37

       Sec. 185.03. A native American tribe having state recognition 38
may carry out any acts or business in this state that native 39
American tribes are authorized to carry out by the laws of this 40
state or the United States. But state recognition as a native 41
American tribe under this chapter is not recognition of that 42
tribe for purposes of the "Indian Gaming Regulatory Act," 102. 43
Stat. 2472 (1988), 25 U.S.C. 2701 to 2721.44

       Sec. 185.04.  (A) A petitioner seeking state recognition 45
under division (B) of section 185.02 of the Revised Code as a 46
native American tribe shall submit to the Ohio civil rights 47
commission a petition that contains both of the following:48

       (1) A certification, signed and dated by members of the 49
petitioner's governing body, stating that the petition is the 50
petitioner's official petition for recognition; and51

       (2) A statement, signed and dated by members of the 52
petitioner's governing body, stating that the petitioner has met 53
all of the criteria for recognition contained in section 185.05 of 54
the Revised Code.55

       (B) The commission shall examine a petition submitted to it 56
and determine whether the petitioner meets the criteria for 57
recognition contained in section 185.05 of the Revised Code. The 58
commission shall appoint a traditional native American council 59
each time the commission is required to make such a determination. 60
The council shall advise the commission in making the 61
determination. The council shall consist of five members and two 62
alternate members. A quorum of the council is three members.63

       (1) The commission shall deny recognition if the petition 64
does not meet, or if there is insufficient evidence that the 65
petition meets, one or more of the criteria for recognition 66
contained in section 185.05 of the Revised Code. A criterion is 67
met if the petitioner provides explanations and supporting 68
documentation that establish a reasonable likelihood of the 69
validity of the facts relating to that criterion.70

       (2) The commission shall consider historical situations and 71
time periods for which evidence is demonstrably limited or 72
unavailable, and fluctuations in tribal activity and the 73
limitations of evidence that may result from those fluctuations.74

       (C) The commission shall approve or disapprove a petition 75
submitted under this section within fifteen months after the 76
commission receives it. The petitioner may appeal the commission's 77
disapproval of the petition to the court of common pleas under 78
section 2505.03 of the Revised Code not later than sixty days 79
after the date of the disapproval.80

       Sec. 185.05.  The Ohio civil rights commission shall use the 81
following criteria in determining whether to recognize a 82
petitioner as a native American tribe under section 185.04 of the 83
Revised Code:84

       (A) The petitioner has been identified as a native American 85
tribe on a substantially continuing basis in this state since 86
1900. Evidence that an entity's status as a native American tribe 87
has been denied periodically by those outside the tribe is not 88
conclusive evidence that the tribe has not met this criterion. 89
Evidence such as the following tends to show that this criterion 90
has been met:91

       (1) Identification as a native American tribe by federal 92
authorities.93

       (2) Relationships with state agencies or political 94
subdivisions of this state based on identification of the group as 95
a native American tribe.96

       (3) Historical and academic recognition of the petitioner as 97
a native American tribe by anthropologists, historians, and other 98
academic scholars.99

       (4) Identification as a native American tribe in newspapers 100
and books and by other state or federally recognized tribes, 101
native American nations, interest groups, or populations.102

       (5) Identification of traditional tribal real property 103
possessions both before and after 1900.104

       (6) Identification of historical figures as being tribal 105
members.106

       (B) The petitioner has existed as a distinct community from 107
historical times through the present. Evidence of the following 108
tends to show that this criterion has been met:109

       (1) Significant marriage rates within the community or 110
arranged relationships with other native American tribes, bands, 111
or groups.112

       (2) The descent of a majority of individuals within the 113
community from individuals recognized as members of a native 114
American group, band, or tribe that is indigenous to the 115
contiguous land area of this state.116

       (3) Significant rates of broad, informal social interaction 117
within the community.118

       (4) A significant degree of shared labor or economic activity 119
within the community.120

       (5) Patterns of discrimination against the community by 121
nonmembers.122

       (6) Shared secular or religious activity within the 123
community, specifically with respect to ceremonies and rituals.124

       (7) Language that is used by members of the community but 125
that is not in widespread use by nonmembers.126

       (8) Cultural patterns or activities that are shared by 127
members of the community but that are not in widespread use among 128
nonmembers.129

       (9) The persistence of a named, collective native American 130
identity by the community over an extended period of time.131

       (10) A demonstrated historical political influence by the 132
community within this state.133

       (11) High rates of marriage within members of the community.134

       (C) The petitioner has maintained political influence or 135
authority over its members as an autonomous entity from historical 136
times to the present. Evidence such as the following tends to show 137
that this criterion has been met:138

       (1) Members consider issues acted upon or taken by leaders or 139
governing bodies of the petitioner to be of high importance.140

       (2) Members widely acknowledge the political process.141

       (3) Members have high rates of involvement within the 142
petitioner's political process.143

       (4) The petitioner's governmental body has had a long-term 144
role in the mediation of conflicts, allocation of resources, and 145
guidance of social interactions.146

       (D) The petitioner has a current governing document that 147
describes membership criteria, and has an official membership list 148
that includes each member's name, including maiden name, date of 149
birth, and current address.150

       (E) The petitioner's membership consists of individuals who 151
descend from an historical native American tribe that is 152
indigenous to the contiguous land area of this state and has 153
functioned as an autonomous political entity. Evidence such as 154
the following tends to show that this criterion has been met:155

       (1) Rolls prepared by a secretary, genealogist, or historian 156
that are used to distribute claims money and other financial 157
allotments.158

       (2) Federal, state, or local antiquated documents; church, 159
school, and other similar enrollment records; and affidavits of 160
recognition by tribal elders, leaders, or the governing body that 161
identify present members, or their ancestors, as being descendants 162
of an historical tribe that was indigenous to the contiguous land 163
area of this state.164

       (3) Recognition of individuals and families, or their 165
ancestors, in oral history as being descendants of an historical 166
tribe that was indigenous to the contiguous land area of this 167
state.168

       (F) The petitioner's membership is comprised primarily of 169
persons who are not members of any other federally or state 170
acknowledged native American tribe.171

       Sec. 185.06.  Native American groups and native American 172
special interest groups are authorized to form, fund, and operate 173
political action committees as defined in section 3517.01 of the 174
Revised Code and are subject to rules adopted by the secretary of 175
state to regulate political action committees.176

       Sec. 185.07. Chapter 185. of the Revised Code is "The State 177
Recognition of Native American Tribes Act."178