As Reported by the House State and Local Government Committee

130th General Assembly
Regular Session
2013-2014
H. B. No. 277


Representative Stautberg 

Cosponsors: Representatives Becker, Brown, Conditt, Hood, Terhar, Thompson 



A BILL
To amend sections 709.02, 709.021, 709.023, and 1
709.033 of the Revised Code to require that the 2
state or a political subdivision real estate owner 3
be included in determining the number of owners 4
needed to sign a petition for an expedited type-II 5
annexation, unless the real estate is a road or 6
road right-of-way, to make other changes regarding 7
that type of annexation, and to change for regular 8
annexations the time at which to determine whether 9
the required number of signatures were obtained.10


BE IT ENACTED BY THE GENERAL ASSEMBLY OF THE STATE OF OHIO:

       Section 1.  That sections 709.02, 709.021, 709.023, and 11
709.033 of the Revised Code be amended to read as follows:12

       Sec. 709.02.  (A) The owners of real estate contiguous to a 13
municipal corporation may petition for annexation to a municipal 14
corporation in the manner provided by sections 709.02 to 709.11 of 15
the Revised Code.16

       (B) Application for annexation shall be made by a petition 17
filed with the clerk of the board of county commissioners of the 18
county in which the territory is located.19

       (C) The petition required by this section shall contain the 20
following:21

       (1) The signatures of a majority of the owners of real estate 22
in the territory proposed for annexation. The person who signs or 23
the circulator of the petition also shall write the date the 24
signature was made next to the owner's name. No signature obtained 25
more than one hundred eighty days before the date on which the 26
petition is filed shall be counted in determining the number of 27
signers of the petition. Any owner who signed the petition may 28
have the signature removed before the document is filed by 29
delivering a signed statement to the agent for the petitioners 30
expressing the owner's wish to have the signature removed. Upon 31
receiving a signed statement, the agent for the petitioners shall 32
strike through the signature, causing the signature to be deleted 33
from the petition.34

       (2) An accurate legal description of the perimeter and an 35
accurate map or plat of the territory proposed for annexation;36

       (3) The name of a person or persons to act as agent for the 37
petitioners. The agent for the petitioners may be an official, 38
employee, or agent of the municipal corporation to which 39
annexation is proposed.40

       (D) At the time of filing the petition for annexation, the 41
agent for the petitioners also shall file with the clerk of the 42
board a list of all tracts, lots, or parcels in the territory 43
proposed for annexation, and all tracts, lots, or parcels located 44
adjacent to that territory or directly across the road from it 45
when the road is adjacent to it, including the name and mailing 46
address of the owner of each tract, lot, or parcel, and the 47
permanent parcel number from the county auditor's permanent parcel 48
numbering system established under section 319.28 of the Revised 49
Code for each tract, lot, or parcel. This list shall not be 50
considered to be a part of the petition for annexation, and any 51
error on the list shall not affect the validity of the petition.52

       (E)(1) As used in this section and in sections 709.02709.02153
to 709.21, 709.38, and 709.39 of the Revised Code, "owner" or 54
"owners" means any adult individual who is legally competent, the 55
state or any political subdivision as defined in section 5713.081 56
of the Revised Code, and any firm, trustee, or private 57
corporation, any of which is seized of a freehold estate in land; 58
except that easements and any railroad, utility, street, and 59
highway rights-of-way held in fee, by easement, or by dedication 60
and acceptance are not included within those meanings; and no 61
person, firm, trustee, or private corporation, the state, or any 62
political subdivision, that has become an owner of real estate by 63
a conveyance, the primary purpose of which is to affect the number 64
of owners required to sign a petition for annexation, is included 65
within those meanings. For66

       (2) For purposes of this section and sections 709.02709.021, 67
709.022, 709.024 to 709.21, 709.38, and 709.39 of the Revised 68
Code, the state or any political subdivision shall not be 69
considered an owner and shall not be included in determining the 70
number of owners needed to sign a petition unless an authorized 71
agent of the state or the political subdivision signs the 72
petition. The authorized agent for the state shall be the director 73
of administrative services.74

       (3) For purposes of section 709.023 of the Revised Code, the 75
state or any political subdivision shall be considered an owner 76
and shall be included in determining the number of owners needed 77
to sign an annexation petition filed under that section, unless 78
the only real estate in the territory proposed for annexation that 79
is owned by the state or a political subdivision is a road or road 80
right-of-way. Only the director of administrative services, on 81
behalf of the state as an owner, or an authorized agent, on behalf 82
of a political subdivision as an owner, may sign a petition filed 83
under section 709.023 of the Revised Code.84

       (4) An owner is determined as of the date the petition is 85
filed with the board of county commissioners, except that any 86
owner whose signature has been removed from the petition pursuant 87
to division (B) of section 709.023 of the Revised Code shall not 88
be counted as an owner under division (E)(2) of that section. If 89
the owner is a corporation, partnership, business trust, estate, 90
trust, organization, association, group, institution, society, 91
state, or political subdivision, the petition shall be signed by a 92
person who is authorized to sign for that entity. A93

       (5) A person who owns more than one parcel of real estate, 94
either individually or as a tenant in common or by survivorship 95
tenancy, shall be counted as one owner for purposes of this 96
chapter.97

       Sec. 709.021. (A) When a petition signed by all of the owners 98
of real estate in the unincorporated territory of a township 99
proposed for annexation requests the annexation of that territory 100
to a municipal corporation contiguous to that territory under one 101
of the special procedures provided for annexation in sections 102
709.022, 709.023, and 709.024 of the Revised Code, the annexation 103
proceedings shall be conducted under those sections to the 104
exclusion of any other provisions of this chapter unless otherwise 105
provided in this section or the special procedure section chosen.106

       (B) Application for annexation shall be made by a petition 107
filed with the clerk of the board of county commissioners of the 108
county in which the territory is located, and the procedures 109
contained in divisions (C), (D), and (E) of section 709.02 of the 110
Revised Code shall be followed, except that all owners, not just a 111
majority of owners, shall sign the petition. To be valid, each 112
petition circulated for the special procedure in section 709.022 113
or 709.023 of the Revised Code shall contain the notice provided 114
for in division (B) of section 709.022 or division (A) of section 115
709.023 of the Revised Code, whichever is applicable.116

       (C) Except as otherwise provided in this section, only this 117
section and sections 709.014, 709.015, 709.04, 709.10, 709.11, 118
709.12, 709.192, 709.20, and 709.21 of the Revised Code apply to 119
the granting of an annexation described in this section.120

       (D) As used in sections 709.022, 709.023, and 709.024 of the 121
Revised Code, "party" or "parties" means the municipal corporation 122
to which annexation is proposed, each township any portion of 123
which is included within the territory proposed for annexation, 124
owners of land within the territory proposed for annexation, and 125
the agent for the petitioners.126

       Sec. 709.023. (A) A petition filed under section 709.021 of 127
the Revised Code that requests to follow this section is for the 128
special procedure of annexing land into a municipal corporation 129
when, subject to division (H) of this section, the land also is 130
not to be excluded from the township under section 503.07 of the 131
Revised Code. The owners who sign this petition by their signature 132
expressly waive their right to appeal in law or equity from the 133
board of county commissioners' entry of any resolution under this 134
section, waive any rights they may have to sue on any issue 135
relating to a municipal corporation requiring a buffer as provided 136
in this section, and waive any rights to seek a variance that 137
would relieve or exempt them from that buffer requirement.138

       The petition circulated to collect signatures for the special 139
procedure in this section shall contain in boldface capital 140
letters immediately above the heading of the place for signatures 141
on each part of the petition the following: "WHOEVER SIGNS THIS 142
PETITION EXPRESSLY WAIVES THEIR RIGHT TO APPEAL IN LAW OR EQUITY 143
FROM THE BOARD OF COUNTY COMMISSIONERS' ENTRY OF ANY RESOLUTION 144
PERTAINING TO THIS SPECIAL ANNEXATION PROCEDURE, ALTHOUGH A WRIT 145
OF MANDAMUS MAY BE SOUGHT TO COMPEL THE BOARD TO PERFORM ITS 146
DUTIES REQUIRED BY LAW FOR THIS SPECIAL ANNEXATION PROCEDURE."147

       (B) Upon the filing of the petition in the office of the 148
clerk of the board of county commissioners, the clerk shall cause 149
the petition to be entered upon the board's journal at its next 150
regular session. This entry shall be the first official act of the 151
board on the petition. Within five days after the filing of the 152
petition, the agent for the petitioners shall notify in the manner 153
and form specified in this division the clerk of the legislative 154
authority of the municipal corporation to which annexation is 155
proposed, the fiscal officer of each township any portion of which 156
is included within the territory proposed for annexation, the 157
clerk of the board of county commissioners of each county in which 158
the territory proposed for annexation is located other than the 159
county in which the petition is filed, and the owners of property 160
adjacent to the territory proposed for annexation or adjacent to a 161
road that is adjacent to that territory and located directly 162
across that road from that territory. The notice shall refer to 163
the time and date when the petition was filed and the county in 164
which it was filed and shall have attached or shall be accompanied 165
by a copy of the petition and any attachments or documents 166
accompanying the petition as filed.167

       Notice to a property owner is sufficient if sent by regular 168
United States mail to the tax mailing address listed on the county 169
auditor's records. Notice to the appropriate government officer 170
shall be given by certified mail, return receipt requested, or by 171
causing the notice to be personally served on the officer, with 172
proof of service by affidavit of the person who delivered the 173
notice. Proof of service of the notice on each appropriate 174
government officer shall be filed with the board of county 175
commissioners with which the petition was filed.176

       Within seven days after the date the agent for the 177
petitioners mails or causes to be personally served the notices 178
required by this division, any property owner who signed the 179
petition may remove the owner's signature from the petition by 180
filing with the clerk of the board of county commissioners a 181
written notice of withdrawal of the owner's signature.182

       (C) Within twenty days after the date that the petition is 183
filed, the legislative authority of the municipal corporation to 184
which annexation is proposed shall adopt an ordinance or 185
resolution stating what services the municipal corporation will 186
provide, and an approximate date by which it will provide them, to 187
the territory proposed for annexation, upon annexation. The 188
municipal corporation is entitled in its sole discretion to 189
provide to the territory proposed for annexation, upon annexation, 190
services in addition to the services described in that ordinance 191
or resolution.192

       If the territory proposed for annexation is subject to zoning 193
regulations adopted under either Chapter 303. or 519. of the 194
Revised Code at the time the petition is filed, the legislative 195
authority of the municipal corporation also shall adopt an 196
ordinance or resolution stating that, if the territory is annexed 197
and becomes subject to zoning by the municipal corporation and 198
that municipal zoning permits uses in the annexed territory that 199
the municipal corporation determines are clearly incompatible with 200
the uses permitted under current county or township zoning 201
regulations in the adjacent land remaining within the township 202
from which the territory was annexed, the legislative authority of 203
the municipal corporation will require, in the zoning ordinance 204
permitting the incompatible uses, the owner of the annexed 205
territory to provide a buffer separating the use of the annexed 206
territory and the adjacent land remaining within the township. For 207
the purposes of this section, "buffer" includes open space, 208
landscaping, fences, walls, and other structured elements; streets 209
and street rights-of-way; and bicycle and pedestrian paths and 210
sidewalks.211

       The clerk of the legislative authority of the municipal 212
corporation to which annexation is proposed shall file the 213
ordinances or resolutions adopted under this division with the 214
board of county commissioners within twenty days following the 215
date that the petition is filed. The board shall make these 216
ordinances or resolutions available for public inspection.217

       (D) Within twenty-five days after the date that the petition 218
is filed, the legislative authority of the municipal corporation 219
to which annexation is proposed and each township any portion of 220
which is included within the territory proposed for annexation may 221
adopt and file with the board of county commissioners an ordinance 222
or resolution consenting or objecting to the proposed annexation. 223
An objection to the proposed annexation shall be based solely upon 224
the petition's failure to meet the conditions specified in 225
division (E) of this section.226

       If the municipal corporation and each of those townships 227
timely files an ordinance or resolution consenting to the proposed 228
annexation, the board at its next regular session shall enter upon 229
its journal a resolution granting the proposed annexation. If, 230
instead, the municipal corporation or any of those townships files 231
an ordinance or resolution that objects to the proposed 232
annexation, the board of county commissioners shall proceed as 233
provided in division (E) of this section. Failure of the municipal 234
corporation or any of those townships to timely file an ordinance 235
or resolution consenting or objecting to the proposed annexation 236
shall be deemed to constitute consent by that municipal 237
corporation or township to the proposed annexation.238

       (E) Unless the petition is granted under division (D) of this 239
section, not less than thirty ornor more than forty-five days 240
after the date that the petition is filed, the board of county 241
commissioners shall review it to determine if each of the 242
following conditions has been met:243

       (1) The petition meets all the requirements set forth in, and 244
was filed in the manner provided in, section 709.021 of the 245
Revised Code.246

       (2) The persons who signed the petition are owners of the 247
real estate located in the territory proposed for annexation and 248
constitute all of the owners of real estate in that territory.249

       (3) The territory proposed for annexation does not exceed 250
five hundred acres.251

       (4) The territory proposed for annexation shares a contiguous 252
boundary with the municipal corporation to which annexation is 253
proposed for a continuous length of at least five per cent of the 254
perimeter of the territory proposed for annexation.255

       (5) The annexation will not create an unincorporated area of 256
the township that is completely surrounded by the territory 257
proposed for annexation.258

       (6) The municipal corporation to which annexation is proposed 259
has agreed to provide to the territory proposed for annexation the 260
services specified in the relevant ordinance or resolution adopted 261
under division (C) of this section.262

       (7) If a street or highway will be divided or segmented by 263
the boundary line between the township and the municipal 264
corporation as to create a road maintenance problem, the municipal 265
corporation to which annexation is proposed has agreed as a 266
condition of the annexation to assume the maintenance of that 267
street or highway or to otherwise correct the problem. As used in 268
this section, "street" or "highway" has the same meaning as in 269
section 4511.01 of the Revised Code.270

       (F) Not less than thirty or more than forty-five days after 271
the date that the petition is filed, if the petition is not 272
granted under division (D) of this section, the board of county 273
commissioners, if it finds that each of the conditions specified 274
in division (E) of this section has been met, shall enter upon its 275
journal a resolution granting the annexation. If the board of 276
county commissioners finds that one or more of the conditions 277
specified in division (E) of this section have not been met, it 278
shall enter upon its journal a resolution that states which of 279
those conditions the board finds have not been met and that denies 280
the petition.281

       (G) If a petition is granted under division (D) or (F) of 282
this section, the clerk of the board of county commissioners shall 283
proceed as provided in division (C)(1) of section 709.033 of the 284
Revised Code, except that no recording or hearing exhibits would 285
be involved. There is no appeal in law or equity from the board's 286
entry of any resolution under this section, but any party may seek 287
a writ of mandamus to compel the board of county commissioners to 288
perform its duties under this section.289

       (H) Notwithstanding anything to the contrary in section 290
503.07 of the Revised Code, unless otherwise provided in an 291
annexation agreement entered into pursuant to section 709.192 of 292
the Revised Code or in a cooperative economic development 293
agreement entered into pursuant to section 701.07 of the Revised 294
Code, territory annexed into a municipal corporation pursuant to 295
this section shall not at any time be excluded from the township 296
under section 503.07 of the Revised Code and, thus, remains 297
subject to the township's real property taxes.298

       (I) Any owner of land that remains within a township and that 299
is adjacent to territory annexed pursuant to this section who is 300
directly affected by the failure of the annexing municipal 301
corporation to enforce compliance with any zoning ordinance it 302
adopts under division (C) of this section requiring the owner of 303
the annexed territory to provide a buffer zone, may commence in 304
the court of common pleas a civil action against that owner to 305
enforce compliance with that buffer requirement whenever the 306
required buffer is not in place before any development of the 307
annexed territory begins.308

       (J) Division (H)(12) of section 718.01 of the Revised Code 309
applies to the compensation paid to persons performing personal 310
services for a political subdivision on property owned by the 311
political subdivision after that property is annexed to a 312
municipal corporation under this section.313

       Sec. 709.033.  (A) After the hearing on a petition for 314
annexation, the board of county commissioners shall enter upon its 315
journal a resolution granting the annexation if it finds, based 316
upon a preponderance of the substantial, reliable, and probative 317
evidence on the whole record, that each of the following 318
conditions has been met:319

       (1) The petition meets all the requirements set forth in, and 320
was filed in the manner provided in, section 709.02 of the Revised 321
Code.322

       (2) The persons who signed the petition are owners of real 323
estate located in the territory proposed to be annexed in the 324
petition, and, as of the time the petition was filed withof the 325
hearing before the board of county commissioners, the number of 326
valid signatures on the petition constituted a majority of the 327
owners of real estate in that territory.328

       (3) The municipal corporation to which the territory is 329
proposed to be annexed has complied with division (D) of section 330
709.03 of the Revised Code.331

       (4) The territory proposed to be annexed is not unreasonably 332
large.333

       (5) On balance, the general good of the territory proposed to 334
be annexed will be served, and the benefits to the territory 335
proposed to be annexed and the surrounding area will outweigh the 336
detriments to the territory proposed to be annexed and the 337
surrounding area, if the annexation petition is granted. As used 338
in division (A)(5) of this section, "surrounding area" means the 339
territory within the unincorporated area of any township located 340
one-half mile or less from any of the territory proposed to be 341
annexed.342

       (6) No street or highway will be divided or segmented by the 343
boundary line between a township and the municipal corporation as 344
to create a road maintenance problem, or, if a street or highway 345
will be so divided or segmented, the municipal corporation has 346
agreed, as a condition of the annexation, that it will assume the 347
maintenance of that street or highway. For the purposes of this 348
division, "street" or "highway" has the same meaning as in section 349
4511.01 of the Revised Code.350

       (B) The board of county commissioners shall enter upon its 351
journal a resolution granting or denying the petition for 352
annexation within thirty days after the hearing provided for in 353
section 709.032 of the Revised Code. The resolution shall include 354
specific findings of fact as to whether each of the conditions 355
listed in divisions (A)(1) to (6) of this section has been met. 356
Upon journalization of the resolution, the clerk of the board 357
shall send a certified copy of it to the agent for the 358
petitioners, the clerk of the legislative authority of the 359
municipal corporation to which annexation is proposed, the fiscal 360
officer of each township in which the territory proposed for 361
annexation is located, and the clerk of the board of county 362
commissioners of each county in which the territory proposed for 363
annexation is located other than the county in which the petition 364
is filed. The clerk of the board shall take no further action 365
until the expiration of thirty days after the date of 366
journalization.367

       (C) After the expiration of that thirty-day period, if no 368
appeal has been timely filed under section 709.07 of the Revised 369
Code, the clerk of the board of county commissioners shall take 370
one of the following actions:371

       (1) If the board granted the petition for annexation, the 372
clerk shall deliver a certified copy of the entire record of the 373
annexation proceedings, including all resolutions of the board, 374
signed by a majority of the members of the board, the petition, 375
map, and all other papers on file, the recording of the 376
proceedings, if a copy is available, and exhibits presented at the 377
hearing relating to the annexation proceedings, to the auditor or 378
clerk of the municipal corporation to which annexation is 379
proposed.380

       (2) If the board denied the petition for annexation, the 381
clerk shall send a certified copy of its resolution denying the 382
annexation to the agent for the petitioners and to the clerk of 383
the municipal corporation to which the annexation was proposed.384

       (D) If an appeal is filed in a timely manner under section 385
709.07 of the Revised Code from the determination of the board of 386
county commissioners granting or denying the petition for 387
annexation, the clerk of the board shall take further action only 388
in accordance with that section.389

       Section 2.  That existing sections 709.02, 709.021, 709.023, 390
and 709.033 of the Revised Code are hereby repealed.391